Contribution
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan. I thank hon. Members for their contributions, and my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) for securing the debate and for highlighting his report. It is fair to say that the issues raised by hon. Members in this debate go right to the heart of our national security for the reasons they covered very well, and which I will also discuss.
Let me be very clear: the report makes an important contribution to our understanding of the economic consequences of hostile state activity. I am glad that my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar highlighted the Prime Minister’s words both in reply to the report and at the Guildhall last night. If my hon. Friend had not highlighted them, I would have done so.
The central argument of the report is powerful: that Russia’s aggression imposes on this country not simply a security cost but an economic cost that is borne by British taxpayers, British businesses and British public services. It is clear that Russia’s hostile activity, from cyber-attacks on our institutions to sabotage on our streets, imposes significant costs. The report estimates that the Putin tax costs the UK £2 billion to £2.5 billion each year and that confirmed incidents alone have generated £1.6 billion to £2.1 billion of economic losses, and argues that the true cost is even higher than those figures.
I think we all acknowledge that the economic consequences of hostile activity do not step at the immediate cost of repairing the damage caused by an attack. They of course also include the costs of disruption to production and supply chains, of recovery and of spending by businesses and Government on increasing resilience. There are also wider economic consequences when services that people rely on—some of which have been well highlighted in this debate—are disrupted. That demonstrates why economic security and national security can no longer be considered in isolation of each other.
Preparing for the world as it may turn out to be is critically important. The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) made that point well, including the importance of stability and certainty to economic growth. That is exactly why we are making the biggest sustained increase in defence spending since the end of the cold war. As hon. Members know, with our NATO allies we have committed to spend 5% of GDP on defence and national security by 2035, including investment in cyber-resilience and infrastructure resilience to protect our economy from exactly the type of threats discussed in this debate.
We are also responding directly and enforcing the toughest ever sanctions on Russia. We are cracking down on those who help the Kremlin to evade those sanctions. Our co-ordinated sanctions action with international allies has deprived Russia of $495 billion to date, and of access to weapons and equipment. The impact of sanctions is clearly seen in Russia’s weakening financial standing: growth has stalled, interest rates remain high, the rouble is significantly depreciated, and the federal budget is expected to remain in deficit throughout this year.
However, sanctions are only part of our response. As multiple members of the Government have made clear, there is absolutely no place for Russian illicit finance in the UK. The hon. Member for North Down (Alex Easton) alluded to that in his valid points around making it more difficult and costly for hostile states to undertake their activity. That is why we are going after the money laundering networks, which have all sorts of complex structures, and the professional enablers that allow sanctioned actors, and others, to hide and move their money. Our new anti-money laundering and asset recovery strategy, which is backed by over £550 million of investment over the next three years, will strengthen the capability of financial intelligence and law enforcement services to target those networks at home.
Part of deterring Russia is of course ensuring that we are at the frontline of European and NATO security. It is important to mention that our support for Ukraine is critical, as has rightly been highlighted during this debate. Russia remains the most acute threat to our national security and the security of our continent. Our economic pressure on Russia and our financial support to Ukraine remain the best policy to support Ukraine and bring Russia to the negotiating table.
It is important to underline that the UK has a broad toolkit to deter, disrupt and respond to hostile state activity, supported by economic security measures including investment screening, export controls and procurement powers. We continue to take action to strengthen our economic security and resilience as all the threats that we are talking about evolve, working closely with regulators, including those in the financial system, as well as businesses and international partners.
Multiple hon. Members have raised the importance of resilience right across our economy and, as they would expect, that is a top priority for the Government. We are continuing to urge all organisations to take action and follow the expert guidance of the National Cyber Security Centre and the National Protective Security Authority. My hon. Friend the Member for York Outer (Mr Charters) made the case very well to follow that guidance and ensure that each business is fully aware of the risks and the importance of resilience.
With regard to the recommendation in the report for the NCSC to publish annual assessments, it publishes an annual assessment of the cyber threat, which includes activity attributed or linked to state and state-aligned actors. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport and the former Department for Science, Innovation and Technology published the cyber-security breaches survey in April, and that research into UK cyber-resilience includes the cost to the economy, as my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar is no doubt aware.
The shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Dumfries and Galloway (John Cooper), rightly raised the importance of the resilience of our financial system, which goes right to the heart of my brief as Economic Secretary. Working with the Bank and the Financial Conduct Authority, we are strengthening the cyber-resilience of our financial system so that hostile states cannot undermine the stability on which every single business and household in this country depends. We are taking forward designations under the critical third parties regime. To the point made by the hon. Member for Richmond Park (Sarah Olney), we have recently—not that recently, actually; it was a few months ago now—designated Microsoft, and it is really important that we continue to keep under review the designations that we have under that critical third parties legislation, because it is a very important tool in our armoury.
The issues that we are discussing today obviously go right across the economy and are not isolated to any one sector. The cyber-security and resilience Bill, as has been raised, will increase UK defences against cyber-attacks to protect the services that the public rely on to go about their normal lives. That Bill will deliver a step change in the UK’s national security, making essential and digital services more secure in the face of cyber-criminals and state actors who will use every tool in their armouries to disrupt our way of life.