B

Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I realise that, by the end of this group, noble Lords will absolutely loathe me as I have 18 amendments in it and I intend to speak on all of them. I apologise in advance for keeping noble Lords here. However, this Bill is important, and it is important to me as a Green Party person who cares about getting people off the roads. One of the things that worries me about the Bill is the fact that the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024 will effectively be repealed in its entirety. This dismantles the protections for public ownership, including that a public sector company must always be wholly owned by the Secretary of State. The Minister has been generous with his time to explain this to me, but it is still a cause of concern for me. However, I do not intend to push any of my amendments to a vote. On Report in the Commons, the Government quietly made amendments to define Great British Railways companies as “subsidiaries” under Section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006. This means that almost any railway function could end up part-owned by the private sector through a range of private shareholding arrangements, including private investors owning just under 50% of a company, provided that GBR retains a controlling stake. This definition was chosen instead of “wholly owned subsidiaries”, also available under Section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006. This much more obvious choice would have aligned with the 2024 Act, which required that public sector companies always be wholly owned by the public. This definition would still allow a broad range of partnerships with the private sector, as can be seen in the example of Platform4, a wholly owned subsidiary of Network Rail. Platform4 has a variety of joint ventures in property development, even as a minority partner at 33%. There is no need for a subsidiary status to enable this. One justification given so far is that a subsidiary status is necessary for property development, but we can see that this is not necessary due to the wide range of joint ventures that are already under way with Platform4. From discussion with the Minister earlier today, the Government’s position appears to be that majority public control is sufficient and that private investment should be permitted where it brings additional money into the railway. I understand the argument for attracting investment, but I do not accept that attracting private investment requires private ownership of companies exercising public railway functions. There is a difference between allowing a wholly publicly owned company to enter into commercial partnerships and allowing private shareholders to earn a substantial stake in the company itself. As far as I understand it, this means that any GBR statutory function in Clause 3(1) could end up part-privatised, so there is no protection even for infrastructure management. Why is the latter necessary? What prevents private shareholders extracting profits from companies whose functions and assets are ultimately part of our publicly owned railway? I also oppose the Government’s Amendment 3. I see this as a complex and worrying two-part amendment that needs a proper clear explanation, not as something that can be brought in and waved through at the last minute. We know from Clause 3(5) that GBR can exercise any of its statutory functions through one or more GBR companies. Proposed new Clause 3(5A) says that such companies should not be regarded as agents for GBR when exercising these core functions. But if that is the case, what other legal relationship is in place and how does that relationship ensure legal accountability? On this point, the GBR licence consultation that has just been published, much too late for consideration of this Bill, tells us that GBR’s subsidiaries will not require their own separate licences and will instead be covered by the parent company’s licence. This also means they will not be accountable to the ORR for licence enforcement. This relationship between GBR and a GBR subsidiary is key, yet here we learn nothing about what it will be—only that it will not be an agency relationship. Why is it thought necessary to exclude agency arrangements in the first place? What relationship will exist instead for functions exercised under Clause 3(5), and how will this provide accountability to GBR subsidiaries? Proposed new Clause 3(5B) says that a GBR company or any other person can exercise core functions of GBR as an agent if it is done outside the arrangements of Clause 3(5). I find this extremely worrying. It seems to be saying that any statutory function of GBR can be contracted out to any person and that all the core functions are eligible to be contracted out to the private sector. This is the first time we are learning that such functions could be carried out outside GBR altogether. What protections are there here for public sector control? Is it the case that literally any statutory function, even infrastructure management, could in theory be carried out by private sector companies under the Bill? Amendment 48 concerns another area where the protections of the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024 are being dismantled. The 2024 Act ensured that mainline passenger rail services would always be awarded to a public sector company, but now we have loopholes in Chapter 1 of Part 2 of the Bill on the designation and exemption of services. It was a strong theme in our Committee—and it is fair to say that it was agreed by Peers across most parties—that there is no clear definition of “designation” and “exemption”, and that there are serious drafting issues in this section. Clauses 25 and 31 require that the Secretary of State “must designate railway passenger services, or a description of railway passenger services”, but only that she “may” secure the provision of those services. Only when the Secretary of State personally secures designated services is there a requirement to do so “by making a direct award of a public service contract … to one or more of Great British Railways or a GBR company”. However, there is no actual requirement for the Secretary of State to secure the services she designates, nor any provision to say how services would otherwise be secured. This omission seems to create space for any type of contract to be awarded by and to any party. This is such a problematic loophole in the Bill that it seems it cannot stand, on the basis of drafting quality alone.

More from Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.