L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I endorse what my noble friend Lord Harper has said about the amendments tabled by my noble friend Lord Lansley, who sadly cannot be in his place today. I have considerable sympathy with the amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw; indeed, in Committee I put my name to an amendment that he had tabled which was very similar in character. It does not seek to constrain the Government in how they spend their money but says that, if the Government were to change a long-term settlement, they must publish, in effect, an impact assessment and explain what its consequences would be. I would have thought that that was something that, when he rises to speak, the Minister might be willing to endorse, because it seems to me good practice. The noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, has had a long and distinguished career in the railway industry and has considerably contributed to your Lordships’ House over the years, having spent 25 years with British Rail and subsequently serving as professor of transport management at the University of Salford. He has brought a wealth of practical experience and knowledge to our debates. Since joining this House in 1999, he has consistently drawn on that experience in scrutinising transport policy and legislation, and indeed other matters. While we may not always agree on every aspect of railway policy, his expertise and commitment to improving our railways are greatly valued across your Lordships’ House. I wish him well in his retirement, which I hope will be happy and long. I turn to Amendments 6, 8A and 47, in my name. Amendment 6 would extend the Secretary of State’s power to issue directions to GBR beyond its statutory functions to its wider commercial activities. I am still left completely baffled as to why the Secretary of State, who is given a power to direct Great British Railways in its railway activities, is forbidden to issue directions in relation to other activities. The parallel with which I am accustomed—as the Minister is accustomed, from past experience—is with the Mayor of London, who also has a power of direction over Transport for London but can direct it in all aspects of its activities if he chooses to do so. As it happens, that is a rarely used power; it has been used only a handful of times during the course of the mayoralty, and then largely for technical reasons in order to facilitate something that Transport for London wanted, rather than to impose on its board something that it did not want. None the less, the arbitrary distinction seems to me quite wrong. After all, let us bear in mind that Great British Railways, in its commercial activities, will benefit from an implicit government guarantee. It will therefore not be an ordinary commercial company in competition with other commercial companies in the same sector. Those activities will certainly include the development of property—that is already envisaged—but may extend to the provision of consultancy services, the development of technology that it wishes to sell and the provision of services to railway undertakings in other countries. These are all possibilities, and, in my view, many of them would be welcome possibilities as commercial activities for Great British Railways, but why should they not be subject to a power of direction? It is an illusion to think that Great British Railways will be operating as an ordinary independent commercial company. In a competitive sphere, it will have a built-in advantage, and it needs to be accountable. What if, in the course of those commercial activities—and I hope this will not happen—Great British Railways loses a load of money? It is the taxpayer, of course, who will have to ante up whatever deficiency exists, and the Secretary of State will be able to say that she was not in any way accountable as she had no power of direction. I know the Minister will say that she can always sack the chairman of the company, but that is a nuclear option, and not something which leads to open debate as to its consequences. Any such action is normally accompanied by confidential documents relating to human resources matters and term and payments, which the Secretary of State would not feel able to discuss in the other place, whereas a straightforward direction, written in black and white on a piece of paper, is something on which she could be questioned and held accountable, as she should be. Such unaccountable commercial activity of Great British Railways is something I warn against. The power of direction is needed if we are going to keep it accountable.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.