L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, before going into the other amendments in this group, I would like to address Amendment 13, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw. He will not be surprised to know that I cannot support it, as I was unable to in Committee. However, before getting into the details of this amendment, I hope the House will permit me some warm words. It is typical of the noble Lord that his valedictory speech is to support an amendment that seeks to put railway funding on a long-term stable trajectory. He, above anyone else in your Lordships’ House, knows why such a trajectory is a good thing. Bill, if the House will forgive me for being familiar, started his career on the railway as a porter at Slough, when I was still at primary school. He became a graduate trainee for British Railways in 1959. He made his way up the ladder of operational management, becoming general manager of the British Railways Western Region in the 1980s. After that, as we have heard, he made serious contributions to transport in Northern Ireland, to the bus industry and to wider transport policy. He is the embodiment of the dedication and commitment, matched with real operational experience, of senior railway managers. Subsequent generations, including mine, look up to him as a fount of wisdom and knowledge, and he has been both an ally and, occasionally and rightly, a critic of mine as the Bill has progressed. I am delighted that he has been here to see the conclusive progress of the Bill, to reunite our railway network into coherent national control. I know I will continue to hear from him, just as the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, will. His emails, like his speech, are pithy and direct. The Government, my industry and I pay tribute to him, as this House does, and we all wish him well in his retirement. To the amendment at hand, the noble Lord is quite right to prompt debate on this. It is true that the railway is a long-term business, with the life of some infrastructure assets, as the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, said, extending for 100 or 130 years. I think the oldest artefact is now 202 years old. I therefore absolutely agree that railway funding must be safeguarded as far as possible. There are clear roles for both GBR and the Office of Rail and Road set out in the Bill. Ministers will always be ultimately accountable for the funding choices of government, but the best outcomes for the railway can be achieved only by listening to the experts put in place to run it. The Bill as drafted requires that the ORR be notified of material changes to funding, as the noble Lord says, before they are enacted. In practice, regular ORR engagement will be a core pillar of GBR’s accountability framework and DfT sponsorship. This means that the ORR will already play an important part in the routine assessments and will have the powers to seek additional information as needed. It is therefore already possible—in fact likely—that, in practice, the ORR will publish assessments of the impact of funding reductions, exactly as the noble Lord hopes. I hope this helps to reassure him and that he might not press his amendment. I will now speak to the amendments tabled in my name. Amendment 3 is designed to correct the drafting of Clause 3 to ensure that it is clear. It would clarify that the current provision which allows GBR to delegate its functions to its subsidiaries does not automatically create an agency arrangement between GBR and the subsidiary. As noble Lords can imagine, contractual partners will want clarity over whether they are partnering with a GBR subsidiary or with GBR itself. If this ambiguity remained in the Bill, it could make GBR a less attractive commercial partner. New Clause 3(5A) inserted by my amendment therefore clarifies that the delegation provision does not by default create an agency arrangement, while new Clause 3(5B) expressly preserves GBR’s freedom to transparently establish such an arrangement if that were to be desirable. This is in line with usual company arrangements and was always the intention of the Bill. My Amendments 22 and 122 were previously tabled for discussion in Committee. They are about providing the ORR with direct consumer law enforcement powers. They would put the ORR on the same footing as the Competition and Markets Authority, which already has these powers, promoting a consistent approach to consumer protection across regulators. For example, this would ensure that consumers receive refunds promptly, rather than waiting for the conclusion of lengthy court proceedings. The amendments will not create new investigatory powers or criminal offences, or interact with criminal law in any way. As I promised the noble Lord, Lord Grayling, should the ORR exercise its powers to enter premises for the purposes of consumer law enforcement, we would expect it to report transparently on its use of those powers. I therefore commend these amendments to the House. I shall now respond to the other amendments in this group, starting with Amendments 47 and 48. The Bill as drafted allows local leaders to make decisions about their rail services if they have been devolved. This is not in opposition to public ownership of national rail services. The key requirement of this Bill is that decisions about passenger services and infrastructure must be brought together within a coherent, accountable system. The best way in which to do this is for the Secretary of State’s passenger services to be provided by the same publicly owned company that is managing the infrastructure. We have seen the risk of misaligned incentives and divided responsibility that national private operation of rail brings, and these reforms will fix those. Equally, it is right to give local leaders the choice about how to deliver those services, once they have been fully devolved. Those two things can coexist, as they do now. On public ownership, I turn to Amendments 2, 126, 128, 130 and 134 from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones. These amendments would not allow for circumstances where it is desirable for a majority-owned but not wholly owned GBR subsidiary to take on activities that would fall within the functions. For example, the amendment would restrict a joint venture from undertaking property development and related infrastructure work, such as constructing a station building, even where that would be the most sensible and efficient way of managing the work. The right approach here is one of flexibility, to allow GBR to harness private sector investment effectively and ensure that future collaborations between the public sector and private sector can be pursued, while GBR also maintains public control and ownership of its core functions. Turning to Amendment 6 from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, I recognise his intention to ensure that GBR remains appropriately accountable for the full range of activities it undertakes, including those arising from its status as a company. As we have discussed before, GBR will be established as a company under the Companies Act 2006 and, like any company, will have the general capacity to undertake activities beyond those set out in the Bill, such as property development. That flexibility is deliberate. However, even though the directions power will apply only to GBR’s railway functions, appropriate oversight of other activities, such as property development, will instead be provided through established shareholder governance arrangements, as set out in the framework document between the Secretary of State and GBR, alongside performance monitoring and funding controls.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.