Contribution
My Lords, the amendments before us would revive policies that this House has previously rejected and which many noble Lords from across the House have raised serious concerns about. They would take us in the wrong direction for industrial relations on the railway and risk undermining the collaborative approach needed to deliver better outcomes for passengers. I hope that noble Lords will again take the view that these measures are neither justified nor proportionate, and will decline to support them.
Amendment 24 relates to workforce pay and the long-term rail strategy. As I said in Committee, I simply do not agree that the long-term rail strategy should be required to include a workforce modernisation strategy. The strategy is not intended to go into specific operational requirements of that nature. Instead, its purpose is to set out the objectives for the railway over a 30-year period, and to consider long-term challenges such as environmental and demographic changes, or technological development. I am sure that noble Lords who have run companies will agree that you do not manage your workforce successfully through long-term, vision-setting documents.
We need to allow GBR the flexibility to respond to operational needs, challenges and opportunities. It is impossible for us to precisely forecast what elements will affect pay for the workforce over a 30-year period. Of course, I would expect GBR to plan its approach to its workforce policy, and all its other policies, around achieving the objectives set out in the long-term rail strategy. It would clearly also be inappropriate to set pay policy for one public sector workforce in legislation. That is not the approach taken with other bodies and it should not be the case for GBR.
Moving on to minimum service levels and industrial action, the previous Government brought in minimum service levels legislation, similar to that proposed in Amendment 49. It was repealed by this Government under the Employment Rights Act, as it did not support a positive or productive relationship between employers, employees and their trade unions. In fact, it served only to exacerbate the national rail disputes under the last Government, which saw two years of widespread strikes and disruption to millions of passengers. Further, while many rail employers, including some controlled by the previous Government, had the opportunity to use minimum service levels regulations, none chose to, as they deemed it either unworkable or unnecessary. I therefore cannot see any argument for including it here and strongly urge the noble Lord not to press his amendment.
Amendment 50 focuses on reforming the threshold for industrial action ballots. The Employment Rights Act 2025 removes restrictions on lawful industrial action because this Government believe that collective bargaining rights are key to tackling problems of insecurity, inequality and discrimination across sectors. We want to foster co-operation between trade unions, employers and the Government, which will support employers to amicably resolve disputes with their workforce, and lead to less disruption and cost overall. This is precisely what we have seen in the rail sector. This Government have improved relationships with the unions considerably and our collaborative approach has meant that the number of rail services lost due to strikes has more than halved compared to under the previous Government.
The cost of settling the disputes that the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, referred to was far less than the cost of continued industrial action that the Conservatives faced, which according to industry estimates amounted to around £850 million in forgone revenue between June 2022 and August 2024—a huge burden that fell directly on the taxpayer. In any event, there was no productivity on the table, because the private sector employers would not table any, as the Government had not agreed what their cut of the savings was.
In any event, as I said in Committee, I reassure noble Lords that the Government and the chair of GBR will consider factors such as productivity when reviewing pay. That is why the Government have already committed that, for pay settlements in 2025 and 2026, any increase above inflation must be in return for productivity. I assure the noble Lord that pay decisions in the future will reflect the Government’s determination to have a motivated, empowered and productive workforce. Before organising industrial action, trade unions must already comply with detailed balloting, notice and procedural obligations. This helps employers plan for industrial action and reduces the impact for passengers. There is therefore no need for the higher threshold proposed by this amendment.
On Amendment 51, this Government will focus on how we work with trade unions constructively to avoid industrial action as far as possible. It is worth highlighting that secondary industrial action is already prohibited under Section 224 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. Trade unions support the creation of GBR and the railway returning to public ownership. They understand that we need to make it a success and that it will take all of us working together to do so. I acknowledge that there are both benefits of a single employer and, as the noble Lord, Lord Harper, and others have said, concerns about the potential for GBR to be a single employer. I assure the House that the Government would not make any such decision lightly or without productivity in mind.
As I said on the fourth Committee day, I will not make commitments about the future structure of GBR at this time because it will be for GBR’s leadership to consider how best it should be structured to achieve its objectives, working with government and in consultation with its employees, trade unions and key stakeholders. Clearly, we all want the railway to work properly for passengers and the public, and there would be no point in me bringing forward any reform that would undermine that.
Finally, I address Amendment 82. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, referred to East West Rail. Of course, the previous Government could have had that railway open in 2024 if they had let a contract in 2022 when it was known that the railway was going to be finished, but it is now this Government’s job to sort it out. Those who listened to the recent hearing of the Transport Select Committee will have heard both the management and the trade unions say that they are in the course of doing so.