Contribution
My Lords, I welcome the support expressed by the noble Baronesses, Lady Harding of Winscombe and Lady Pidgeon, and the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, for the Government’s amendments. I believe we have reached a sensible decision on retail and fair access, and I will turn to the other issues raised during the debate.
First, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for Amendments 43 and 44. The Government fully recognise the importance of maintaining a fair and open retail market. Competition and innovation can deliver real benefits to passengers through improved products, services and ways of purchasing tickets. That is why Great British Railways will remain subject to competition law in full and why we have developed the retail code of practice. Both the ORR and the Competition and Markets Authority can exercise enforcement powers in relation to GBR through the competition law framework, while the ORR can also enforce GBR’s compliance with the code. I assure noble Lords that the ORR’s competition duty will apply to the ORR when it is writing and developing the code, ensuring that the principle of competition is embedded as fully as possible in the code itself. We have not applied a competition duty to licence enforcement simply because enforcement should be fair and based on one factor: whether the operator has complied with the code and licence. The ORR should not be taking enforcement action against operators that are entirely compliant with the rules, simply because it is driven by other legal duties that are not relevant to its work as an impartial enforcement body.
I turn to funding and transparency in Amendments 16, 18, 19 and 21. Great British Railways will remain subject to competition and subsidy control law, which prohibits distortive cross-subsidisation. As GBR retail will be integrated into its wider operational business, we also do not anticipate that GBR will be funded in the same way as an independent retailer. GBR’s passenger services activities, including retail, will instead be funded under the transport-specific framework that sets out the applicable subsidy control provisions to those activities—the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations, or PSOT 2023—and captured as part of GBR’s integrated business plan. That is how train operators are funded today and it ensures that funding is linked to delivery of specified activities. Funding received cannot exceed the net cost of delivering those activities, the costs of which will be agreed with the Secretary of State through GBR’s business plan. GBR cannot receive more money than is necessary to deliver the retail function set out in the business plan, and nor can money be diverted from infrastructure to support retail operations.
There will also be sufficient public transparency to allow external parties to understand the level of funding being provided to GBR retail activities, so they can be reassured that GBR is using its funding fairly in line with requirements set by the Secretary of State. GBR will be required through its business plan to set out its activities, such as its broad retailing function, the costs of these activities and how it proposes that these costs are met. That should provide sufficient transparency to allow external parties to understand the funding of GBR’s passenger services. However, facilitating identical comparisons between GBR’s costs and those of independent retail is not appropriate, as many of GBR’s costs will be shared across activities. For example, its customer service centre will support a wide range of passenger inquiries, not just ticket sales. This reflects its role as a public transport operator retailing through all channels, not an online retailer. Furthermore, just because it is funded differently, that does not mean it can use this funding in a way that damages competition in the market.
GBR will be subject to competition law in full when discharging its functions and using public funding. Should the ORR suspect that its use of retail funding represents a breach, it has all necessary powers to investigate and enforce against GBR, including powers to require any information it needs for its investigation from GBR, which will be fully transparent with the regulator.
The use of BT and Openreach in telecoms as an analogy of GBR in the retail market is tempting but ultimately represents an apples and oranges comparison. Openreach is a wholly owned subsidiary of BT Group and a dominant telecoms infrastructure manager. It is Openreach’s costs and revenues that BT Group reports on separately; it does not report separately on, for example, its commercial customer-facing part of the business that sells broadband to consumers. Regarding rail retail, it is the cross-industry retail systems previously or currently managed by the Rail Delivery Group, and in future by GBR, that are the Openreach equivalent, not the costs and revenues from GBR selling its own tickets. The costs of these cross-industry retail systems are shared fairly by those who use them and, as part of our commitment to fair, transparent and non-discriminatory access, the code explicitly requires GBR to pay a proportionate share of these costs going forward.
It is therefore the Government’s position that the existing level of transparency, combined with the protections in the code of practice and existing competition and subsidy control law, are sufficient to ensure that GBR is funded fairly and a fair and open market is secured for all retailers. I therefore ask noble Lords not to press their amendments. I beg to move.