L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, on Amendments 17, 20 and 38, while I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that railways need to become more efficient with taxpayers’ money, I do not agree that these amendments would create the right incentive or generate the right behaviours in Great British Railways to achieve that. In my view, there is a tangible difference between minimising taxpayer subsidy and getting the best value for money out of the subsidy that the Government choose to put in. Minimising costs pushes the balance towards GBR cutting costs and raising fares, rather than seeking true efficiency and getting the most value out of every pound in the railway. The balance here is so important because of the knock-on impact that the imbalance can have on the longer-term prosperity of the railways and the wider social and economic benefits that the railway can provide. I think we all agree in this Chamber that a well-functioning railway delivers more than the sum of its parts and that connectivity provides opportunity and productivity. A branch line that operates thanks to public subsidy also allows people to get to work or their place of education or to see family and friends. It is a valuable part of a wider economic picture. GBR should be incentivised to run such a line in the most efficient way possible, not to close it down because that would deliver the lowest cost to the taxpayer. As I said in Committee, it was that kind of thinking that led to the Beeching closures and those subsequent to them, and I do not think any of us wants to see a repeat of that. In addition, sometimes to get more out of the railway in future, there needs to be investment in the present. This Bill should not risk giving GBR no incentive to try to find opportunities and present them to government, which can decide whether to fund those opportunities based on the fiscal circumstances at the time. In summary, I do not believe that the role of GBR is to cut the cost of the railway; it is to deliver the objectives of the Government of the day in the most efficient way, whether that objective is simply to cut costs or something else. The Bill fully provides for this model and already includes consideration of value for money. The Secretary of State will be able to set out their objective in the statement of objectives. GBR will need to create a business plan in response to those objectives, considering its duty in Clause 18 to make efficient use of public funds. Finally, the ORR will provide independent, expert advice to the Secretary of State about whether this plan represents the achievement of their objectives and good value for money. Under the Bill as drafted, at every step in the process, from planning and funding to delivery, value for money is considered. That is a better and more balanced approach than one that incentivises a race to the bottom, as these amendments would do. I hope the noble Lord agrees and sees fit to withdraw his amendment.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.