Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)

I think it is worth reminding the House that I spent my entire working life in the financial services industry in one form or another, and I am afraid to say that my practical experience of the industry has made me a sceptic of much of the promotion provided by it telling us how it will do the economy a favour. Does my noble friend agree that there are potential downsides to the financialisation of the economy that seems to lie behind these proposals? We need to realise that there is a form of resource curse in overfinancialising the economy. There is also a dynamic within the industry driven in large part by the inevitable asymmetry of information. You can provide all the education and explanation that you wish, but there will still be this asymmetry of information leading to a succession of scandals. There is a dynamic in the industry—in personal pension scandals, endowment scandals and the Northern Rock scandal there was a dynamic that has to be recognised. Finally, I am concerned that, in the Statement, the Government appear to be giving people financial advice. I am sure my noble friend will deny that that is what they are doing, but saying that the Government are going to get people better financial returns is a very dangerous path to go down. Does my noble friend the Minister accept that there is a need for robust safeguards for ordinary investors? I press him to accept that those appear to be contemplated by some of those commenting on these proposals. Significant weakening is a grave danger to the economy and individuals.