Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)

I welcome the opportunity to take part in this interesting debate. It is the second time that I have intervened in what appears to be a series of debates on this issue. The last time I was guilty of a degree of naivety. It turned out that it was not a debate about tumble dryers; it was really a debate about Brexit and the Windsor Framework, just as today’s debate—although quite a few references have been made to plant health, seeds and potatoes—is really at heart a debate about where we are with Brexit and the associated Windsor Framework. Why are we here? Given the time available, I want to make just three points about Brexit. First, it was sold on a false prospectus, of which “take back control” was one of the most egregious. It was a lie. We do not have control in an interconnected world to the extent we were told. Secondly, the terms of exit were negotiated, in my view, incompetently—not least of which was the failure to appreciate until too late the implications of a land border between the UK and the European Union. Thirdly, it is worth making the point that a majority of people in the United Kingdom now regard Brexit as a mistake. These are all thoughts that need to be borne in mind when undertaking this debate. Finally, given the nature of this debate and why it is happening, it is relevant to point out that, in the Brexit referendum, a clear majority of the people of Northern Ireland were against leaving the European Union. In fact, the majority in favour of staying in Europe was somewhat greater than the majority across the UK as a whole who wished to leave.