L

Lord Faulks (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I do not for a moment dispute the right of the Government to bring forward legislation imposing a duty of candour. It was in the manifesto, and in any event, there is generally agreement across parties that public authorities and officials should be candid. The need for this has been graphically illustrated by Hillsborough, the Post Office and many other scandals. The requirement for the creation of a criminal offence, such as we see in Clause 12, was not in the manifesto. Even if it had been, it does not relieve your Lordships’ House of the task of scrutinising the legislation, particularly a clause which has such a wide potential scope. Clause 12, described just a moment ago by the Minister as a “bold step”, will create an offence of misleading the public by public officials. It is a free-standing criminal offence. On conviction, a defendant could face up to two years’ imprisonment. A public authority includes a Minister of the Crown, a government department, the devolved Administrations, the Armed Forces, police forces, local authorities, NHS bodies, schools and any other body with functions of a public nature. A public official, which appears, in this context, to include those who work for a school, is anyone who works for or holds office under such a body. My first question to the Minister is: can he clarify quite how many public officials would be caught by this definition so as to render them potentially liable to conviction of a serious offence? We heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Falkner, that there are some 6 million civil servants, but there are many others who would classify themselves as public officials, and we have a significantly large public sector in this country. My second question is: what sort of behaviour is intended to be caught by this clause that would not be captured by the provisions of the Bill—Clauses 13, 14, 17 and 18—or by the general criminal law? Examples would help. I looked at the Explanatory Notes. One of the examples given was a department covering up “the harmful consequences of a policy”. With respect, that seems to describe what government is regularly accused of doing in the rough and tumble of politics, yet it could apparently be a criminal offence. The clause is extremely vague, which gives rise to rule-of-law objections. As we have already heard, “misleading” is a tricky word. When is a political statement that tends to emphasise positive rather than negative facts—or vice versa, depending on the source—to be regarded as “misleading”? “Seriously improper” is defined, but it includes not only an act of concealment but “obfuscation”. What is or is not “obfuscation” is very difficult to say. There is a defence—which I think the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, will address to the Committee—that is supposed to provide some form of defence. At the moment, I am not convinced of how satisfactory it is. If the Conservative Front Bench had its way, a prosecution would proceed only with the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions or the Attorney-General. Is this a sufficient safeguard? I am not seeking to impugn the integrity of any DPP, but will he or she not have to take some very difficult, almost political decisions? We know that prosecuting authorities can be judicially reviewed, and that mischievous people can attempt prosecutions for political reasons. My provisional view is that this offence, although motivated by the best motives, is a big leap forward—one that potentially renders people vulnerable to prosecution who should be not the intended victims. While many people who might be prosecuted might be acquitted, they would still have to go through the process of being subjected to the criminal justice system. That is the first point. The second point—which is perhaps more important—is the question of what effect this particular provision will have on public administration. I recommend the Policy Exchange document on the Bill that was published last week, and in particular the foreword by the noble Lord, Lord Butler, who knows a great deal about public administration. The authors of the paper drew comparisons between the now much-regretted Freedom of Information Act and this piece of legislation. I looked to see what the periodical Local Government Lawyer—probably not a publication terribly familiar to your Lordships—might say about Clause 12. Generally, the publication is not politically contentious; it is there to guide local governments as to potential legal vulnerabilities. It said this of the Bill: “The breadth of the offence will likely require existing codes of conduct, employee policies, protocols and training materials to be revised. Anti-corruption measures will be familiar in many public bodies, but may not … capture the full range of behaviours that will be criminalised by Clause 12”. That sounds like an absolute avalanche of legal intrusion into the way that public authorities will have to operate in the future. If the Freedom of Information Act 2000 was supposed to change the culture of secrecy, it has, in many people’s view, made people reluctant to commit frank views to paper at all. Many feel that it has had the opposite effect to that which was intended and has not made for better government. Clause 12 similarly runs the risk of making officials much more reluctant to put provisional or controversial views on paper. Decisions may be taken only in small groups. Notes may well be taken very much with the prospect of being scrutinised. We heard earlier in debates about the problem of people potentially deleting notes or deleting digital footprints. There may not be anything to delete if this becomes law. Lawyers will be involved and lawyers do not always help make good decisions, whatever their intentions. It may well be that the people involved in making decisions feel that they had better not write anything at all. To reassure the Whips on the Front Bench, I am not intending to divide the House over this issue, but I am seeking to probe the Government on how this is going to work. I had some sympathy with the amendment spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, on the requirement for harm. This is a step into the unknown which I am not convinced will be satisfactory. In fact, I fear the worst.

More from Lord Faulks (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.