Contribution
My Lords, there have been some important points made and I am sympathetic to the arguments put forward by the noble Lord, Lord Faulks.
I keep thinking that there will be unintended consequences of this. It is difficult because—and I do not say this in a sarcastic way—this is a very worthy, noble Bill. I do not want to betray its intentions, but I fear that if we do not challenge it and scrutinise it properly, it will itself betray what it is trying to do by creating a whole new set of problems.
In our previous day in Committee, the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, raised some important points about the dangers of overcriminalisation and the damaging outcomes it could have. Clause 12 fits very much into that spectrum.
I also have a lot of sympathy with the criticisms made by the noble Lord, Lord Young, of Amendment 72 on the provision of misleading information to the press and how that could be used or interpreted. Inasmuch as the press is a valuable way to hold power to account, it is very important that we do not inadvertently do anything that stops the press getting hold of some more difficult stories. People might not intend to mislead—we can think of malevolent reasons for the press being told lies about people—but things might be said to the press in good faith, when we want to encourage more whistleblowing to the media, not less, if we are to shine a light on wrongdoing in society.
I have some hesitancy here, but I put my name to Amendment 74, which seeks to include as an offence a civil servant misleading a Minister. In a way, I was trying to respond to the notion of a two-tier issue. Documented cases exist in which civil servants and senior officials have provided incomplete, inaccurate and misleading information to Ministers or have kept key facts from them. We are aware of this and, as the Civil Service Code requires honest and impartial advice and supposedly prohibits deliberately withholding relevant information from Ministers, it might seem extreme if we now say that this should be made the law and a legal offence created. But, in a way, that is what the whole Bill does.
I am a bit torn on this. The inquiry into the Post Office/Horizon IT scandal was told that officials had misled Ministers or had failed to provide accurate, impartial advice. There have been accusations that Ministers were misled on everything from the scale of the backlogs of asylum and immigration cases to the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan. That has been documented in the Foreign Affairs Committee and elsewhere. To quote that committee, civil servants were
“at best intentionally evasive, and often deliberately misleading”.
That is an atrocious situation.
I do not want to let Ministers off the hook and get into a cheap “blame the blob” situation, but I have experienced situations such as a Minister reading out advice, in relation to issues of sex and gender—as it happens—when I challenged their interpretation of the Equality Act 2010. The Minister read out information that was inaccurate and misleading, and I felt this was driven by a more ideological intervention, because I challenged the Minister and they were just reading out what they had been given. The Supreme Court might have clarified this, but the law was the law before it clarified what it was. Ministers had been given bad advice and yet it was difficult to challenge that. That made me consider taking this amendment seriously.
I am going to completely contradict myself now because, having put my name on that amendment, I have changed my mind. This is a bit unhelpful, but it might help if I explain why I have ended up somewhere else. It suddenly dawned on me that those officials could well claim that they were simply using good faith judgment to advise the Minister; they were not trying actively to mislead, even though I have some sympathy with the notion that a lot of the Civil Service is overly ideological and too partial on some highly contentious issues.