L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

Perhaps, then, there is every excuse for her not to know this, but she will find there quite a detailed analysis from me as to why the franchising system had ceased to be effective. It has been fully acknowledged that a number of systemic reasons, to which Covid was added as a practical final nail in the coffin, meant that the franchising system did not work. However, that did not mean that there was no role for the private sector; the concession model was available as an alternative. As I have said in Committee previously, we believe—and we are quite right in saying this—that there is no rationale for going for a fully state-owned, Soviet-style railway that is run and provided by the Government and wholly excludes private sector competition except, at the moment, certain residual open access routes. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, who has, with her customary textual acuity, put her finger on something that the Government need to explain: why the Secretary of State “must”—they have no choice—designate routes on the one hand but then “may”, and only “may”, procure them. A number of objections to this have been raised. Two former Secretaries of State for Transport have said that they think it undesirable for the holder of that office to have this power. I am not going to dissent from that argument, but I have my own questions because I am not entirely sure what it means to designate a service. The noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, also asked about this; the nub of what he was asking was, “What does it mean to designate a service, especially if you don’t have to provide it? It is only the case that you may provide it if you choose”. Does this mean that Great British Railways can provide only services that have been designated? If it does not mean that, and it can provide other services over and above those that have been designated, what is the point of designating? Or does it mean that the designation of a service, which may not then be procured, relates only to services that Great British Railways does not want to run or does not have a financial incentive to run? Is it, therefore, a sort of obligation on Great British Railways, which may then be procured from Great British Railways, thus forcing it to provide such services? These might be loss-making, commuter-type services that need heavy subsidies and which Great British Railways would close down if it were interested only in covering its own costs. Nobody quite grasps the point of designation in the first place, whoever does it and whatever the consequences of it. We would like to hear more about that. We would also like to hear more, at the simple textual level, about what “may” and “must” actually mean and how they interact between Clauses 25 and 31. This goes back to the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Jones; although I do not agree with her on what the effect should be, we all agree, I think, that the text should make some coherent sense. So the Government have quite a big job to do in explaining all of this to us at this stage. Before I move on to my own amendments, I wish to express support for the amendment standing in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, which does not apply only to heritage railways; we will come to this again later on, I think. This power on the part of Great British Railways to go around seizing private assets will, I imagine, be possible only after the Government have come round to supporting the Conservative policy of leaving the European Convention on Human Rights, because that would preclude them from going around seizing private assets. What do the Government intend here, and why should they be trusted with such broad and unlimited powers if they have only a very limited and specialist focus in view? That is, to some extent, the question being asked by the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner. My own Amendment 157 is a detailed sort of amendment. Clause 32(3) exempts Great British Railway’s award of contracts being published in advance. I can certainly see that, in a competitive tendering situation, the main point of publishing contracts that will be awarded in advance is to allow people who wish to bid for them to have fair and equal knowledge of what is coming up so that they can make a decision about whether to bid and put the resources into doing so.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.