Contribution
My Lords, I shall be fairly brief in opening this debate, although it contains a large number of amendments in my name, because the real purpose is to give the Government an opportunity to set out their policies and plans on two crucial areas. The first, which is connected to Amendment 161, relates to fare evasion, which has become, as I think everyone is aware, very much more a social issue, a problem and a widespread crime than it ever has been in the past. It needs tackling and attention given to it. Government information estimates that between £350 million and £400 million a year is lost through fare evasion and ticketless travelling.
Fare evasion is associated with another great social evil which concerns me and I know concerns the Minister—assaults on railway staff. They remain a significant concern, and fare enforcement can itself be a trigger for threatening or violent behaviour. It is no longer the solitary ticket collector wearing his uniform wandering up and down the corridor on the railway collecting fares. Now, it is of necessity a group of three or four revenue protection officers working closely together as they go through the railway car seeking to collect fares. That is because of the potential for violence, which now has to be reckoned with and taken very seriously in a way that was never the case in the past.
Last month, the Government confirmed that they are developing a new cross-industry framework, supported by improved data sharing, to identify persistent fare evaders, deter repeat offending and recover unpaid fares. Can the Minister shed some light on what that framework is going to involve? Will it form part of the long-term rail strategy? My Amendment 161 would require the long-term rail strategy to include credible plans for dealing with fare evasion and for the protection of staff, particularly in that connection. When do the Government expect the framework to be published and implemented?
Turning to Amendment 161A, I want to explore a question of some political interest. Both the Minister and I were closely involved with Transport for London in different capacities for a number of years. One of the features was that the fares were set by the mayor. Not many people always realised this. TfL made many operational decisions but did not, in fact, have the power to set the fares for its own services. One might say that that is a bit odd, but the advantage of giving that power directly and personally to the mayor was political accountability, in that the mayor could be held responsible for the setting of fares by Transport for London for its passenger services. I know that there are pros and cons to that.
My amendment opens the discussion around the role of the Secretary of State in setting fares. As far as I can see, under the Bill as drafted, the Secretary of State has no role in the setting of fares. Therefore, there is no accountability for fares to the public or to Parliament. Of course, in a normal business, it could be said that, if you set your fares or your prices too high, your customers will go elsewhere, but, in this Soviet-type model, there is nowhere else to go—except for the odd residual open access service that might be allowed to continue in operation for a short time. How do we square this circle? How do we have fares set in a way that is not directly and obviously open to political manipulation but has a degree of accountability so that the customer, who has nowhere else to go and no choice to make, cannot simply be ripped off? Because it has followed this ideological route, I do not think that the Bill gives a satisfactory answer to that question, so I would like to hear what the Minister has to say about it; I am sure that he has given it considerable thought, but, in my view, it has not been satisfactorily resolved.
I have a number of other amendments in this group: Amendments 162 to 164 and 166 to 175. I will briefly speak to them in one go. They concern discounts on fares. The Government have given verbal assurances that veterans and former members of the Armed Forces, for example, will have their discounted travel on the railways maintained, but nothing in the Bill protects the categories that exist at the moment. Indeed, should they be protected? Is it the Government’s intention that they should be protected? We do not know.
At this point I should say that I am—it will not surprise noble Lords—the possessor of a Senior Railcard. When I book my ticket and click the drop-down box to find the Senior Railcard so that I can take advantage of it, the list of railcards from which I could choose is huge. Some of them are regional cards; some are for strange categories of person. They have obviously built up over a long history and never really been weeded—should they be? What is the Government’s intention? None of this is vouchsafed to us in the Bill, and no protections are put in place for those persons we believe should continue to benefit from those discounts. These amendments are there to explore all that and to give the Government the opportunity to put on the record now, at the Dispatch Box if not in the Bill, what their clear intentions are and what commitment they are making to those who benefit from discounted rail travel at the moment. I beg to move.