Contribution
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, on this group of amendments, most of which refer to the cases of assaults on British women by US military, which we canvassed extensively in Committee. These are horrific cases; I think I could fairly say that your Lordships looked horrified about them—and absolutely rightly.
I was pleased to attach my name to Amendment 50 from the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton. It is clear that what we are talking about here is something that needs to happen, and I very much hope we might hear the Minister and the Government acknowledging that, since we need to know how big the scale of this problem is. We only know about the problem at all because of extensive, and no doubt expensive, journalistic work by the Guardian. I hear tell that a number of further cases are likely to emerge in the near future, including one where the US military did not inform the UK police at all. Therefore, this is something we need to keep track of, which is what the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, has done.
Some of that information was uncovered using freedom of information requests, but those do not always produce a result and are again reliant on individual initiative, which we should not be relying upon. The point made by the noble Baroness about the need for reporting to Parliament, so that Parliament actually knows what is happening here, is crucial. The final subsection of her amendment is also interesting. Saying that the decision would not take effect until the Secretary of State has reviewed and approved it is crucial. We need to see serious political responsibility taken for any decision that denies a British victim of serious sexual crime the protection of the British courts, and any person who is found to be a criminal should receive what the British state—the British Government and the British people—regard as an appropriate punishment. This is not something that should be handed over, practically ever. I cannot see any arguments for that.
I come to my Amendment 51, which the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, has kindly backed. This brings back the amendment I had in Committee, because I am afraid that the assurances we had then from the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, did not address the fundamental problem: the need for stronger safeguards. The existence of legislation is not enough if it fails to protect victims in practice. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, referred to the letter from the chair of the National Police Chiefs’ Council but, as she said, that is only guidance: “Please think about doing this”. We know how much pressure our police forces are under in terms of resources—and if you do not react to that letter, there is no obvious penalty or action to be taken in response.
The Minister also referred to the Crown Prosecution Service guidance, but guidance alone is not a sufficient safeguard, particularly when questions remain about how the existing arrangements have been interpreted and applied. The approach should start from a clear principle: the UK should retain primary jurisdiction over alleged offences committed here against victims, particularly, or perhaps not solely, those with no connection to the visiting forces. There has to be clear justification for any departure from that principle, under narrowly defined circumstances. It should not appear to start from the circumstances in which a foreign service court has primary jurisdiction, and then explain why the UK does not. The presumption should be that the UK retains responsibility, unless there is a compelling and legally justified reason otherwise.
We should also be very cautious about treating notifications of victims as a sufficient safeguard. As we canvassed extensively in Committee, what victims are told and what they understand, the pressure they are under and the shock and suffering they have been through, does not necessarily equip them to make a reasonable judgment of what they really want to happen, or what they might, on reflection, have wanted to happen. The Government have acknowledged the seriousness of the cases that brought this issue to our attention, and I appreciate the Government’s desire to see a review, but identifying lessons and issuing guidance are not the same as clear legislation. If the Government agree that jurisdiction should be ceded only when absolutely appropriate, why are they unwilling to put the independent decision at the heart of the process?
That concludes my comments on my amendments and those of the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton. I will just say, probably to no surprise of the House at all, that the Greens are against Amendment 56.