Contribution
My Lords, my Amendment 233 in this group is not about heritage railways, but I strongly support the efforts that the noble Lord, Lord Parkinson, has made in raising that issue on several occasions—ingeniously, when it comes to procedure. My amendment is about a completely different subject: timetables and the provision of information to the public about what trains are actually going to run and when.
It is extraordinary that we have reached a point when most or many operating companies simply do not publish or produce timetables. We are therefore dependent on information obtained from station staff or the use of apps and websites on a telephone or iPad, which is often very impractical. Many people find it a difficult method to use to get information about what trains are available, and people find it particularly difficult if they are rushing around. Perhaps they are on a shopping trip to Edinburgh, it is raining and there is a crowd in the street, and the only way to find out when the next train will be is to open their phone and find the appropriate site and garner the information from that. It results in a situation that I shall come to in a moment.
In the meantime, I want to say that LNER on the east coast main line has actually produced a timetable. Noble Lords might cheer at that point until they discover that it expired on 16 May 2026 and has not been replaced. Furthermore, if you looked at it in more detail, you would discover that it did not contain any trains of any operators other than LNER, even though, when LNER reduced the service from stations such as Berwick and Durham, it said that it was not a problem because people would be able to use connecting services and pick up its trains further down the line. Those connecting services are wholly absent from the timetable.
Station staff at stations such as Berwick get frequent requests from people saying, “I’m going to Edinburgh for the day—what time can I come home? What trains are there? I am not sure what time I’ll finish my business or my shopping trip in Edinburgh”. So what do the staff do? They produce a timetable on their own initiative—I have it in my hands; it is a strip of paper about six inches long and an inch wide. It tells you every train from Edinburgh from all the different operators, but it is a desperate measure produced by a staff who are not provided with the tools to keep rail users properly informed. That applies particularly on lines where services do not follow a regular clock face patten, as is the case for most stations on the LNER main line.
I have discussed this with the Minister. We had a lengthy meeting some time ago, and I think that he agrees with me that it is ludicrous to have timetables that include only one operator’s trains when the journey may well depend on two operators’ trains. These things are thought to be about to disappear by magic—once GBR is in place, all these conflicts and difficulties will evaporate, we are told—but I am afraid that they will not unless some provision is made and the public is informed about when trains go.
My amendment is a bells and whistles, Rolls-Royce version of a timetable. My case is not that we have to go back to the mammoth timetable volume—of which I am sure the Minister always had a copy, long before he was in his present post—which gave you every train on every line in the country. I found that useful, but it is not what most people are after—most people would want a more local timetable—but they have no timetable at all, neither in a form that they can carry away nor in the form of a poster in a station, listing the train times. Very often, when you are in a station, you do not just want to see the electronic display of the trains in the next hour; you want to see what trains are available later in the day.
If you are making a journey, you do not necessarily want simply to get onto a website and find out which train to get if your plan is to leave at 9 o’clock. You might want to look at the timetable and consider whether it is feasible to stop off at York for a couple of hours and make a visit out of your day. All these sorts of things that people did with the aid of local and regional timetables are not provided for.
The purposes of my amendment could be satisfied in a more limited form, but modern technology should enable GBR, which will have to produce a working timetable anyway, to make available a proper timetable to meet the needs of its customers. Its absence is a handicap to encouraging rail use.