L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I shall speak relatively briefly to this group since we covered some of these issues in the previous group. I reiterate my congratulations to my noble friend Lord Parkinson, but I will not repeat my praise for Dean Forest Railway apart from just mentioning it. I want to reference two amendments in this group. Amendment 231 in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan I think would be very valuable. It proposes that when producing the infrastructure capacity plan GBR would have to consult people. The current drafting of the clause says that GBR must issue the document, “setting out how, in its view, the best use can be made of GBR infrastructure” It says: “When preparing, revising or replacing the document … Great British Railways must have regard to the need to accommodate ... GBR passenger services, … other railway passenger services, … services for the carriage of goods by railway, and … the maintenance and improvement of GBR infrastructure”. I note that it always lists GBR passenger services first. Again, this may not mean anything legally but, mentally, it rather suggests that that is the order in which it is going to prioritise railway services because that is the order in which it is listed. When doing lists, people tend to put the important things at the top. As the noble Lord, Lord Tunnicliffe, said, it will make people think that that is how GBR will allocate it. At the moment, the clause refers to producing a document with GBR’s views. It does not say that it has to consult anybody. My noble friend Lord Moylan’s amendment proposes that it would have to, “consult and have regard to the views of other railway passenger services”, a reference that I think would be very valuable and welcome to those operators. It would mean that when producing the infrastructure capacity plan, GBR would have to talk to them and listen to them seriously. I also wish to touch briefly on Amendment 234, again from my noble friend Lord Moylan. It would replace part of Clause 63 and would deal at least partially with the issue that I raised when we were discussing Clause 63 in the previous group. It would remove GBR’s ability to preference its own services and refers equally to freight, open access operators and GBR’s services. It would stop GBR being able to reserve capacity for the future, which I think would be welcome. I am not wedded to the form of words tabled by my noble friend. If, when the Minister does his reflection that he referred to on the previous group, he would like to come back with something different, that would be fine. This is a helpful starter for 10, as it were, for dealing with some concerns raised by my noble friends Lord Lansley and Lord Young of Cookham and me about Clause 63 in the previous group. When the Minister reflects on this group and this issue, I hope that he will look at the amendments tabled by my noble friend with an open mind.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.