Contribution
I am very privileged to follow the noble Lord, Lord Anderson. When he started his speech, I thought I would disagree with him, but by the time he finished I agreed with every word he said. He mentioned the Constitution Committee, of which I am a member, as it stands, and it is now dealing with vulnerabilities and threats to our constitution.
The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, talked about how students were once taught about the British constitution. I taught just that in the 1970s and early 1980s. In the first lecture the students were completely bewildered when I said that there was no constitution to teach them. They thought there was. Over the following 18 months to two years—as we went through everything from the monarch to the judiciary to Parliament, and everything else that constitutes a Government and Parliament in this country—they began to realise that we did indeed have a constitution. Some of it was written; some of it was convention; some of it was historical; some of it was good; and some of it was bad. But what it was not was a written constitution.
Over recent years, as the Constitution Committee will undoubtedly report, there have been threats and vulnerabilities to our constitution, not least of which is the rise of populism. Who knows what might happen if a hard-right Government took over? The Reform Party has already said what it would do, and it is not on its own. Would a written constitution stop it? I am not sure it would—that the constitution as we see it is strong enough to withstand those threats. It is very important that we try to change it where it needs to be changed, in the way we have done for many years. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, has touched on the ways in which we can strengthen our constitution without going to the extent of writing it all down as a complete written constitution.
The noble Lord rightly mentioned the Cabinet Manual. At the moment, it is relatively worthless because it is entirely based on the whim of a Prime Minister. The only way it could be made absolutely perfect would be to codify it in law, through statute. The Constitution Committee will probably look at that in further detail. Look at the way in which Members of our House are appointed. The committee which appoints them is not statutory in the sense that it can do what it wants; it is still at the whim of a Prime Minister. Perhaps that could be codified and put into law to improve our constitution.
What I am particularly interested in, as a Welsh Member of this House and someone who spent his entire ministerial career in the territorial departments, is how devolution has changed the nature of our constitution over the last 30 years. The constitutional and political landscape has completely changed. All three of the Governments and Parliaments in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland were set up by statute and then confirmed by referenda. Indeed, I took the Northern Ireland Act 1998 through the House of Commons, and that Act is effectively a constitution for the running of Northern Ireland. There have been other Acts since which have clarified different things, but that Act and the similar Acts for Wales and Scotland—incidentally, they said that sovereignty was vested in the people, which is something quite different from what we have heard in the past—formed the basis of the constitution of those countries.
However, they are in a sense themselves under threat. In Edinburgh, Cardiff and Belfast, the Governments of those countries are now effectively in the hands of nationalists. Of course, they are perfectly legitimate political parties. In Northern Ireland it is not as simple, as it is half and half, but the First Minister is Sinn Féin. In Edinburgh, the First Minister is SNP and in Cardiff the First Minister is Plaid Cymru. All parties are committed to independence. What happens if they have a referendum in each of those countries? In Northern Ireland, it would be the border poll, and it would be a referendum in Scotland and in Wales. If that happens, we will not be talking about a British constitution but an English constitution. That is a severe threat to the constitution of our country of the United Kingdom which needs to be taken very much into account.
Soviet Russia under Joseph Stalin had a constitution. It guaranteed all the rights of freedom of the press, freedom of association and the rest of it. It was entirely fiction—worthless. It does not mean to say, if you have a written constitution, that it protects anything if someone is going to overthrow it by coup or some other method.
In the United States, the President, as mercurial as he is, has almost complete control of the separation of powers which de Tocqueville talked about. He has a Supreme Court which is compliant, Republican majorities in both houses, and he uses Executive orders on a whim. That is a written constitution, which was meant to protect the liberties of the subject, so take care. We might see a change in a few months; we can only hope.