L

Lord Howard of Lympne (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen. Unfortunately, I am no more able to agree with him today than I was during the many years we served together in the other place. I have only one point to make. The one certain effect of the adoption of a written constitution would be the transfer of power from elected parliamentarians to unelected judges. This is because under a written constitution, the final word on our laws would rest with the judges. Under our present arrangements, if the courts interpret the law in a way Parliament considers undesirable, Parliament can legislate to put matters right if it so chooses. Under a written constitution, it would have to amend the constitution—a process which, by design, would be made very difficult. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, in his opening sought to circumvent this by suggesting that you could have a watered down written constitution which would not quite have the effect I have just described. But the whole point of a written constitution is, to a greater or lesser extent, to hamstring the sovereignty of Parliament and that is what I consider undesirable. Of course, democracy is not perfect, and of course, it does not always deliver the verdict that any of us might want, but if those who are elected fail to deliver what they were elected to do, they can be ejected from power and replaced by others. Democracy is, in a real, literal sense, power to the people. If an extreme totalitarian Government were elected—which I believe would never happen in this country—does anyone think they would be deterred from pursuing their agenda by the niceties of a written constitution, any more than the Russian Government, just mentioned, are deterred by the provisions of Russia’s written constitution? Of course, there are some, not least some judges themselves, who regard judges as the ultimate personification of all that is noble, wise and good—in contrast to mere politicians, who have to pander to the demands of the electorate, or, as the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, put it, with the faintest hint of disparagement, day-to-day politics. They may well be right in their characterisation of judges that I have just described, but judges are not elected, nor should they be. That is why they should not be granted the ultimate power, which a written constitution would confer upon them. The transfer of power from elected parliamentarians to unelected judges has been happening under our current arrangements. It has happened as a result of the extension—by the judges, not by Parliament—of the scope of judicial review. Most of all, it has happened via the coming into force of the Human Rights Act—a transfer of power for which Parliament itself was, most unwisely, responsible. However, that transfer of power would be considerably extended by the adoption of a written constitution. In due course, it would inevitably lead to demands for political oversight of the appointment of judges, so candidates for judicial office could expect to be closely questioned on their political views. I do not think most people would welcome the importation to our shores of the practice whereby judges of the US Supreme Court decide on the date of their retirement by reference to the political make-up of those who would select their successor. What mischief is this proposal designed to remedy? Our current arrangements have, by and large, served us well. With a few modest adjustments, returning to Parliament the power that has recently been transferred to the judiciary can, and will, serve us well in the future. A written constitution is something we do not need; it would do us harm and should not be introduced.

More from Lord Howard of Lympne (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.