B

Baroness D’Souza (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, I too thank the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, for providing the opportunity for this debate and for his far-reaching introduction. This is a huge issue. We have heard various views expressed on the pros and cons of a codified constitution. I am not entirely sure that I have much to add to what has been expressed, but I would like to touch on the role that Parliament could play in ensuring scrutiny and monitoring of constitutional Bills to ensure that they receive the attention that they deserve and need. My premise in so doing is that it is the experience of this House over many years that incremental reform is more likely to succeed than sweeping changes. In the last decade or so, constitutional issues have come into sharper focus, whether it be the Brexit process and Prorogation, the successful rulings by the Supreme Court in 2017 and 2019 on the Gina Miller challenges, or on aspects of devolution. There have been repeated questions about the integrity and ethics of the Government of the day. What emerges is the lack of clarity on where exactly power lies in our uncodified constitution. The centuries-old chivvying between the Government, the courts and Parliament was eventually resolved by the adoption of supreme parliamentary sovereignty as the basis of the English settlement. Parliament can make or break any law and, in theory at least, this power is constrained by a set of checks and balances. The problem is that these checks and balances have proved weak, resulting in, among many other developments, public distrust of the Government of the day and of our political institutions. There are now new elements to contend with, notably the impact of external forces—forces outside government—which, by their wealth and influence, are creating a new global order. There is an urgent need for action to reassert the UK’s fundamental constitutional principles. However, a serious attempt to rewrite our uncodified constitution would be a huge undertaking, lasting possibly several years, with an uncertain outcome. Furthermore, it would require widespread consultation and efforts to educate the public on complex aspects of law. That said, no one denies that there is a case for action. What kind of action would serve to educate and allay the concerns of the wider public, including the media? One of the main recommendations of the 2023 Review of the UK Constitution, published by the Institute for Government and the Bennett School of Public Policy, was the establishment of a new and possibly joint parliamentary committee on the constitution. The committee would have several functions, including scrutinising constitutional policy and monitoring adherence to norms and conventions. The review points out some of the weaknesses in the present arrangements, such as the tendency for the Government to pass devolved legislation often without the consent of the respective devolved nations, or the reliance on a simple parliamentary majority for changes such as fixed-term Parliaments, only to have them abandoned by a similar simple majority. There is also the reversion to referendums—for example, on Scottish independence and Brexit—by a public who may not take into account the unintended consequences. This committee could usefully begin by listing existing constitutional Acts and principles and new categories of constitutional Acts, thereby formally recognising the importance of key legislation that underpins our system. The present constitutional arrangements are relatively unclear. A single independent and authoritative source of constitutional knowledge would be of great help in clarifying the legitimacy of different party-political views which have no mechanism for resolving disagreements. In due course, this committee could perhaps take on greater powers, such as the power to delay legislation until the constitutional aspects are formally agreed following pre-legislative scrutiny. The rationale in focusing on the constitution is that we can no longer ignore the contradictions of the political instability that is emerging. The public need reassurance, and the Government need to be prepared to deal with new challenges so as to underpin protections that we already have but do not adequately adhere to. The recommendations in the IfG review suggest a way forward that would significantly improve parliamentary oversight, promote public understanding and trust, and serve to clarify our constitutional laws.

More from Baroness D’Souza (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.