B

Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, for securing this debate, and so clearly and entertainingly introducing it, even though I profoundly disagree with his conclusions. It will probably not surprise your Lordships’ House when I say that I am going to bring a very different perspective to any heard thus far in this debate. I thank the noble Lord also for giving me the opportunity to explain a discussion I was forced to truncate back in 2020, when the respected commentator, David Allen Green, took a letter I had written to the Financial Times in a manner that I had not intended. I was in fact agreeing with Mr Green and an article he had written headlined: “The UK’s constitution is not working”. He responded on the social media site then called Twitter, feeling incorrectly that I had meant to slight him. The internet rule of not feeding the fire meant I did not have a chance to fully explain then, but I can now. The newspaper had put the headline on my letter: “It’s time the UK had a written constitution”, which was an accurate, although not complete, description of the letter’s contents. What I called for was a modern, functional, democratic and written constitution. I described what we have now as “a tangle of historical accident held together by a gloss of tourist-friendly ceremony”. The constitution is not democratic. We still have a massive Labour majority—if with a different leader—that was won in 2024 with the support of 33% of the people who voted: about 25% of eligible voters. The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, referred to the extreme position we have of parliamentary sovereignty, and this is a Parliament that does not reflect the views of two-thirds of the British people. The constitution is not functional. There are so many examples, but one I will point to is the wide agreement around the House on the abject failure of scrutiny of legislation in the Commons. The noble Lord, Lord Rooker, has taken to highlighting this, to general House approval. The constitution is not modern. Visit the FCDO offices and they are like a time machine; you return in a flash to the Victorian empire, as the report The World in 2040: Renewing the UK’s Approach to International Affairs, highlighted in 2024. Going back to 2020, my focus then—and now—was not primarily on the written aspect of the constitution, although there is an argument going back to the law of the 12 tables in ancient Rome, when the plebeians demanded, and finally secured, written laws against which the actions of patrician judges and officials could be tested. If that basic safeguard of being written down is not there, insiders will always have the advantage. What I would have said to Mr Green is that the existence of a written constitution of course does not ensure constitutional behaviour—something I am all too concerned, as are the majority of Americans, that we are about to see close up and serious in the US midterms and the next presidential election there. However, it would be an important democratic step forward, taken in Rome in about 450 BCE, that the UK has yet to secure. However, of course it is not a panacea. No single step will solve all our problems, and anyone who tells you they have a cure-all patent medicine should immediately be discounted as a serious thinker. What would be crucial now is the process of creating a written constitution, to debate and consider. Here I respectfully disagree entirely with the noble Lord, Lord Carter. I believe we need to have that debate. Currently, we have toxically buried a huge amount of disagreement in our society. If we do not have that debate, the agreement will continue to fester. In that process, what might we consider? What is the UK and what is its place in the world? Should there still be a UK? That is now very seriously in question, and I note that it is challenged by the Green parties of both Scotland and Wales. Should we have such a massive dominance by Westminster over the rest of these islands? Should we get the big money out of politics, not all of us getting the politics the few pay for? Should we still have the last rotten borough: the City of London? After all, the position of the City of London as a global centre of financial corruption is a failure not just of governance but of government. What does the constitutional monarchy mean? What about the Crown Estate? Should who anyone’s parents are determine their place in our constitution? Should we have an elected upper House? The noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes, will give us a chance to talk about that tomorrow, so I will leave that there. These and many more are the questions that I suggest should be considered by a people’s constitutional convention that would be at the heart of a broad national debate. As the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, said, the constitution is a matter for every citizen; I would say it is a matter for every resident of the UK. The status quo benefits the status quo. That is not a stable and sustainable situation; it cannot continue. I have to respectfully disagree with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett of Maldon, that written constitutions arrive in a time of political upheaval and change, but that does not apply to the UK—this after we have had seven Prime Ministers in 10 years and are now known internationally as “Westminster on the Tiber”.

More from Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.