L

Lord Kerr of Kinlochard (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

“Up to a point, Lord Kakkar”, as Evelyn Waugh might have very nearly said. I agree with the general thesis, but I think HOLAC needs to be on a statutory basis and with a wider remit. I once tried to write a constitution for the European Union. It was a constitutional treaty. Mine was merely the pen; the ideas came from representatives of 28 legislatures and 28 Governments, including four active present Members of this House. My treaty was a total failure. It was accepted by 18 countries, but it was vetoed by two and I think it would have been vetoed in this country if it had come that far. Are there any lessons that I can bring to the House from my sad experience of having failed to write a constitution, or having written a constitution that failed? I am prepared to try, if noble Lords insist. We failed principally because the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, was not involved. He could have warned us not to be so ambitious, as he warned three years ago in his famous lecture and as he has warned again tonight. In his lecture, he distinguished three kinds of constitution writing. He warned against a revolutionary approach, starting from scratch—a Grundgesetz. He recommended for this country an authoritative restatement of current constitutional arrangements, making them easier to grasp. As again today, he spoke of a programme of modest renewal, dealing with problems that are thrown up by recent history. I think HOLAC is a case in point. Excessive use of framework laws worries me greatly, and the Independent Adviser on Ministerial Standards and the Advisory Committee on Business Appointments, which seems to be a revolving-door committee, could both be looked at. All these defects are ones which most of us in this House hope Mr Burnham will address. The Anderson prescription is evolution, not revolution. I concur with my noble friend: I am uneasy about the suggestion, though I do not know how valid it is, that Mr Burnham is still attracted to something like the German basic law. The EU constitutional treaty that failed was actually not far from the Anderson prescription. It was mainly restatement, but the provisions in it that attracted most opposition were in fact provisions it was restating. They were already operative when they attracted enormous opprobrium in France, and a certain amount in this country, and they remained operative after the treaty was rejected. The elements that were new—the new parts of the European Parliament, the European Council’s enhanced status and presidency, and the bulwarks against competence creep—were not in themselves revolutionary, and 95% of them were subsequently adopted and are operative now. It was putting them all together in a single new compendium text that killed them in 2005. It looked an intimidatingly big package, and a vanishingly small proportion of those who rejected it in France, in the Netherlands and, I suspect, in this country had actually read it. I draw two conclusions from that sad history. First, restatement and renewal, as the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, prescribed, should be entirely separate exercises. Secondly, renewal should be tackled seriatim in a rolling programme over time. Every innovation will have an opponent, and the opposition to a compendium will amount to more than the sum of individual criticisms—so no German basic law, please. It would need countrywide acceptance, presumably by referendum. It could easily suffer the same fate as my EU masterpiece, and a failure would do lasting damage because it would be very hard to distinguish and disentangle the acceptable from the unaccepted. In my view, we should not just think about the relationship between Executive and legislature. We also need to think about the relationship between this legislature and those in Belfast, Cardiff and Edinburgh, and the relationship between central and devolved governments, as the noble Lord, Lord Murphy did. I hope that Mr Burnham, when he preaches devolution, looks beyond England. As a Scottish unionist, I strongly resented the way that recent union Governments patronised and insulted Edinburgh. I was and remain uneasy that consultative intergovernmental mechanisms were so little used and interparliamentary consultation so vestigial. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett, commended conventions, but our elastic interpretation of the Sewel convention seems to me to be dangerous and dishonourable. That convention, written into the Scotland Act 2016, says we will not normally legislate in devolved matters without the consent of the Scottish Parliament. However, we never should, and the inclusion of the promise that we will not normally cheat is an open invitation to cheat, which has all too often been exercised. Devolved means devolved, and we should bind ourselves never to claw back competencies when it suits us. We Scots are great at grievances, so let us not create real ones. Let us honour the constitutional settlement we have and go in for some cautious reform and renewal, along the lines of the Anderson prescription.

More from Lord Kerr of Kinlochard (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.