V

Viscount Stansgate (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, I am very pleased to contribute to this debate, not least because I welcome any opportunity to debate the constitution. Being so low down in the list at least gives me the opportunity to say what a wonderful debate it has been so far. I commend the noble Lord, Lord Anderson of Ipswich, for securing the debate and for his speech. I find myself rather missing my noble friend Lord Hennessy of Nympsfield, who would be making a contribution if he were here. I am very grateful to the Library for the briefing it has given, setting out the arguments for and against a written constitution. As we heard the noble Baroness, Lady Manningham-Buller, pay tribute to the distinguished career of her father, I would like to thank the Library for including in its briefing a reference to the 1991 Commonwealth of Britain Bill, introduced by the then right honourable Member for Chesterfield. We know that we do not have a single document that contains our constitution; we have a variety of laws and judicial decisions, customs, conventions and precedents. However, we do not just have written documents, we also have pictorial ones. Earlier this year I went to the British Museum to see the Bayeux Tapestry, and I recommend that all Members do the same. In a way, that tapestry is a foundational document of our constitution, because the events that followed the Battle of Hastings have laid the foundation for the system of government we have today. The Prime Minister has set out his case for greater devolution. No 10 North is a symbol of his commitment and, in due course, it may well be that this will lead to new developments in our constitutional arrangements, but they will be evolutionary. That is not quite the same thing as saying that it will inevitably lead to a brand new written constitution for this country in a single document. Apart from anything else, it would be remarkably difficult to create and agree a written constitutional document setting out the relationship between the various branches of government, the individual rights and sovereignty of the people and so on. That is not to mention the need to consider the way in which it might be ratified. There may be Members of this House, people present now, who have studied the founding of the United States, as I have. The Federalist Papers and the debates in Philadelphia culminating in the document written in 1787 represented a great achievement at that time. It remains one of the most robust and successful in modern political history, though I am bound to say that it is currently under strain, to say the least. We have yet to see how stretched that constitution can be by current events. Ask me some more after 3 November, but that is a debate for another day. I do not think it feasible or practicable for us to create a single written constitutional document today; frankly, we have had too much history to make that possible. If I may gently say so to the noble and learned Lords here present, nor would it be right or desirable to create a constitution that would inevitably confer on the judiciary a major responsibility for its interpretation. Call me old-fashioned, but I am a believer in parliamentary sovereignty, and I may as well add that I was brought up to be so. For those who argue that a written constitution is a vital bulwark against the abuse of power, I would argue that written constitutions are not immune to bad actors, a point made by many people so far. Of course, there are weaknesses in unwritten constitutions. A recent example was the attempt to prorogue Parliament for a long time in 2019, though that did not eventually succeed. Some have raised other weaknesses. I recently saw the evidence given by the noble Lord, Lord Case, to the Constitution Committee of your Lordships’ House. His argument for a written constitution was that it was remarkable for a G7 country, a P5 member of the United Nations and a nuclear power not to have a clear line of succession—a not unreasonable point. What would happen if our Prime Minister was run over by a bus today? The only thing I know for certain is that the passengers on that bus would have not paid more than £2 each for the journey. Seriously, though, what would the line of succession be? I do not claim to know. We do not at the moment have a designated Deputy Prime Minister, though we have had at various times in the recent past. Some might claim that this is a fatal weakness. I think the situation would be resolved. I am sure we would probably have an interim leader, then an election of the Labour Party and events would unfold in a familiar way. The underlying point I am trying to make is that our unwritten constitution would, in effect, cope with such a situation, as it has with others, because ultimately it rests on the consent and the confidence of the people. This concept of confidence is a central part of our unwritten constitution. After all, we have a system in which the very definition of a Prime Minister is that she or he has the confidence of the House, and the political system has the confidence of the people. This year has seen a pretty classic example of what happens when a Prime Minister loses their confidence. Where there have been attempts made to import a rigidity into our constitution, such as the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011, they have failed because it did not work and it was realised that we need to retain the flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances—even if it means, as the country knows well enough, that this adaptation has meant six Prime Ministers in seven years. There is one thing I want to raise. Others have mentioned it, but that is a disadvantage of being down the list. It is the issue of the Cabinet Manual. If there is one point on which I hope my noble friend the Minister will reply, it is to update the House on progress on the next edition. The origins of the manual go back to the document Questions of Procedure for Ministers in the 1970s. It was updated by the noble Lord, Lord O’Donnell, who I am glad to see in his place, and Lord Hennessy of Nympsfield, with the direct support and encouragement of the then Prime Minister, whose interest in the architecture of British politics is well known and to be respected. I am one of those who have long campaigned for a new edition of the manual. My time is up, so I urge my noble friend to tell us how progress is going, what the process for approval might be, what consultations there will be in both Houses and when it will be published. Following that, I hope this House will have a debate on it, because it would make a fitting sequel to our debate today.

More from Viscount Stansgate (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.