B

Baroness Prashar (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Written Constitution

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, for securing this debate and for his masterly introduction of it with a light touch. Andrew Blick and Peter Hennessy, in their book The Bonfire of Decencies: Repairing and Restoring the British Constitution, written following the Boris premiership, highlighted how the experience of the Johnson premiership demonstrated the fragility of our uncodified constitution. They argued that muddling through is no longer feasible. They said that, although the system self-corrected, these excesses are a warning. More recently we heard that Prime Minister Burnham has said that the greater devolution of powers within the UK strengthens the case for a written constitution, and he made reference to the German model. In recent years, the UK constitution has been under pressure for reasons such as Brexit and Covid. Calls for a written constitution are not new. Arguments for and against are well rehearsed. However, in my view what is clear is that our uncodified constitution needs attention. A full-blown constitution through which we move from parliamentary supremacy to judicial supremacy is not the answer to the concerns expressed. We need evolution, not revolution. The flexibility and merits of our current arrangements were very well articulated by the noble Lord, Lord Carter of Haslemere. I agree with what he said, so I will not repeat it. However, the current constitutional arrangements need enhancement in areas such as violation of conventions, unlawful activities of a challenging nature, violation of criminal law by Ministers, breaking treaty obligations and international law, compromising public institutions and associated values, and eroding any mechanism that exists to police or limit overriding rules, conventions and limitations—for example, Parliament, courts and oversight bodies, particularly those of a constitutional nature. Our current arrangements depend on these structures, and their robustness and respect for them. The underlying changes faced in the recent years necessitate a look at the problem as a whole and not piecemeal tinkering. There have been a number of inquiries, with recommendations and suggestions which need to be brought together and considered as a whole. There have been several Select Committee inquiries and recommendations. I was involved in one two years ago: the governance commission, which was chaired by Dominic Grieve. We need a cross-party commission which considers the recommendations already made and examines where the weaknesses are in our current arrangements—what needs to be strengthened and where we need harder enforcement. Such an exercise would address the problems as a whole and their combined effect. This process could be used to encourage public awareness and show why respect for rules and conventions matters. The “hidden wiring” of our constitution, as described by the noble Lord, Lord Hennessy, needs to be made more explicit in a document that is accessible. That can then be underpinned by the recommendations made by the Institute for Government, to which the noble Baroness, Lady D’Souza, referred. Those arrangements would work well. While such an exercise is necessary, it is not sufficient, because the environment within which it operates also needs attention. No constitution can function satisfactorily without a strong political realm that addresses the lack of trust and confidence in government and democratic institutions, that tackles the decline of and lack of participation in political processes, and that creates initiatives to restore confidence in democracy, the lack of which has given rise to populism, authoritarianism and consequent social divisions. That is equally, if not more, important. We need to strengthen and enhance our current constitutional arrangements and foster values that bolster democratic behaviours and encourage the engagement of citizens. This is where devolution can help. Properly implemented, it can bring decisions closer to communities, strengthen local leadership and enable a greater public voice; through deliberative engagement, it can foster social cohesion. True participation rests on the capacity to come together, build trust and have shared spaces for dialogue and collective problem solving. It is these that need to be woven into devolution, not just a constitutional change. Devolution is not just an administrative task or a rearrangement of the constitution but a genuine community-building task. If we neglect this, we risk devolution that will be technical but socially brittle. Ultimately, constitutional success depends on human beings rather than just written documents. Our uncodified constitution needs to be refreshed and reformed, not torn down and replaced. Will the Government take a comprehensive look and not just continue to muddle on?

More from Baroness Prashar (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.