B

Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, who finished where I am going to start, with the huge powers of direction that the Bill provides to the Secretary of State. His amendments are directed primarily towards parliamentary accountability; my Amendment 39 is about keeping decision-making power local. This amendment would “prevent the Secretary of State from using the general power of direction to determine individual local commissioning decisions, while limiting directions on specialised services to defined national purposes”. The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, said that his amendments are probing. I am afraid that mine aims to suggest a way forward for the Government, because I suspect that we will find in many amendments in this area that the House wants to see something happen with the overweening power that the Bill currently provides. As the noble Lord said, this appears to be going in the opposite direction of what the Government say their intentions are for the devolving of power and resources down to local areas. What we have here is a fundamental question about where decisions on the NHS should be made and who should make them. Of course there should be national standards and accountability, but that is very different from giving the Secretary of State the power to intervene in the day-to-day commissioning decisions of local health bodies. My amendment talks about things such as “the opening, closure or relocation of a particular NHS service or facility … the location at which a … service is provided” and who should provide services. As the Nuffield Trust has pointed out, the English NHS is already unusually centralised, compared to other similarly sized health systems. The Bill takes us even further in that direction by giving the Secretary of State powers to intervene in integrated care boards well beyond those currently available to NHS England. The powers over NHS foundation trusts exceed the powers that the department held even before NHS England was created. The concern is that these powers might be used not simply when an ICB is failing but when it is not following the political interests, personal prejudices or even whims of the Secretary of State. Integrated care boards exist to make commissioning decisions that reflect the needs of their local populations. Those needs vary across the country and Westminster does not necessarily—or even very often—understand such individual regional differences. The health challenges facing a rural community are not necessarily the same as those of an inner-city population, but a large inner-city population may have more political clout than a dispersed rural one. The availability of services, transport links and local demographics all matter. Decisions about where a service is provided, whether a facility should open or close or which provider should deliver care require an understanding of those local circumstances. They should not be a matter of political direction from Whitehall. I think we can all imagine the real risk that these powers will encourage Ministers to announce some great input into an individual hospital facility or services without properly understanding the consequences for the community concerned, or indeed from political motivations. We are talking about the potential for political favouritism, with decisions influenced by that rather than the needs of patients. The amendment would prevent the Secretary of State using the general direction power to make individual local decisions, but the separate intervention powers under Section 14Z62A remain available. It recognises that specialised services are different; they are often complex, expensive and relatively rare and there is a strong case for national consistency and collaboration between integrated care boards there. In relation to specialised services for clearly defined national purposes, the amendment therefore allows directions for “determining which services should be commissioned as specialised services”, ensuring compliance with national standards and commissioning policies, and requiring collaboration between ICBs. We would be allowing national co-ordination where it is needed without providing an open-ended power to micromanage local healthcare. It is difficult to see how meaningful devolution can take place if local health bodies know that the decisions they make can be overridden by the Secretary of State. Local bodies must have the freedom to make decisions and the accountability that goes with that freedom. We should be building an NHS where local leaders are supported to make decisions based on evidence, professional expertise and the needs of their population, not a system where they are looking over their shoulders and anticipating the next political intervention from Westminster. We know that that kind of central control can encourage defensive decision-making, discourage openness and make it much harder to have honest conversations about the challenges facing local services. This amendment seriously aims to offer a practical way forward: it would preserve the Secretary of State’s ability to intervene when an ICB is genuinely failing and ensure national co-ordination of specialised services, while protecting the integrity of local commissioning decisions.

More from Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.