Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Victims’ Commissioner, Women’s Aid and the wider groups of charities and NGOs that make up the group that specialises in domestic and sexual abuse work, which continues to work tirelessly to ensure that victims and witnesses are treated appropriately during their time in the courts system. Because of the way the Bill is set out, we have to table similar amendments for the criminal courts and the family courts in some of these areas because they relate to different parts of the Bill.
Amendment 47A sets out how those giving expert evidence in criminal proceedings must be overseen by a regulatory body or profession. The reason for this is that, in recent years, people have been giving evidence as experts who in reality are not qualified, expert or held accountable to their profession for the evidence if it is not expert or independent. I declare an interest here. My husband, a design electrical engineer, has been an expert witness in criminal and civil cases. He is a member of the Institution of Engineering and Technology, the IET. In becoming a member of this professional body, he had to demonstrate that he had the appropriate academic and professional qualifications. Being a member of that body would reassure all those in the court case that he was able to provide evidence to assist the court.
However, there has been a tendency in recent years in all three courts—criminal, civil and family—for people who are not members of a regulatory body or profession, and whose qualifications to speak may therefore not be expert, to call themselves experts in an area. The CPS’s definition is:
“Expert evidence is admissible to furnish the court with information which is likely to be outside the experience and the knowledge of a judge or jury … An expert witness can provide the court with a statement of opinion on any admissible matter calling for expertise by the witness if they are qualified to give such an opinion … The duty of an expert witness is to help the court to achieve the overriding objective by giving opinion which is objective and unbiased, in relation to matters within their expertise. This is a duty that is owed to the court and overrides any obligation to the party from whom the expert is receiving instructions”.
There are references there to which Criminal Procedure Rules these refer to. It continues:
“CrimPR 19.2(3)(d) also obliges all experts to disclose to the party instructing them anything (of which the expert is aware) that might reasonably be thought capable of undermining the expert’s opinion or detracting from their credibility or impartiality”.
Unfortunately, in the court system there are no formal standards or regulations relating to them to guarantee that they can demonstrate that expertise. This amendment sets out a definition of a regulated expert and says a court must not admit expert evidence given by an unqualified person other than in truly exceptional circumstances. It also says the Lord Chancellor must designate bodies that people should register with and specify the standards and codes of practice used for compliance.
The family courts, and to a lesser extent the criminal courts, have found themselves with unqualified so-called experts, mainly in psychotherapy, whose independence has been questioned. But this is not just about psychiatry and psychotherapy experts. If regulation is brought in for experts across the board, using their professional body or regulator, it will strengthen juries’ confidence that the expert witnesses have the expertise that is needed and the skills to understand that they are servants of the courts, not promoting their own issues, which I am sorry to say has happened more recently.
I also have Amendment 47B in this group, a probing amendment that our colleagues tabled in the Commons. It would require the Government to make regulations extending the protections in Clauses 8 to 10 to other offences whose complainants are victims within the meaning of the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024. The existing eligibility is too tight. This proposes to use the helpful definition in the Act. Clause 8 covers compensation claims relating to sexual offences, Clause 9 is on false complaints and Clause 10 is on evidence of propensity to commit offences involving domestic abuse. Amendment 47B seeks to ensure that the protection for victims elsewhere applies here too.
Amendment 52B is my final amendment in this group. It
“seeks to create a presumption that child witnesses, and complainants in section 17(4) offences, may give evidence by video recording or pre-recorded cross-examination if they wish. The court must grant the direction unless it is satisfied that refusal is in the interests of justice and must give reasons if it refuses”.
This amendment and the others I have laid are trying to help clarify and smooth the processes for vulnerable people and victims facing a complex courts process that is impenetrable to them.