L

Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, as was the case at Second Reading, on these occasions the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, and I tend to come at matters from a slightly different direction from the majority of noble Lords, particularly those who have a legal qualification. While a lot of the discussion is about the intricacies of the legal profession and areas where it is particularly sensitive, we come at it from a different direction. Despite all the nuances in the judicial system, its problems and the rules within it, we are concerned about what actually happens to the victims. If all these attempts by the judicial system to make things work to its own satisfaction have the opposite effect on victims, it is important that their voices are heard. That is what is behind this group of amendments. I support Amendments 47A and 47B from the noble Baroness. I agree that the amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, goes even further, so I support that even more. However, I will speak primarily to Amendment 49, which is about the victim’s right to review. As the noble Baroness said, we have tried to argue this case on several occasions, not least when the late lamented Baroness Newlove was here and was able to speak with all the force that came from her own searing personal experience, as well as the experience she had in being instrumental in setting up the role of the Victims’ Commissioner and then, on two separate occasions, holding it in a very distinguished way. Essentially, we are trying with this amendment to enable the CPS to discontinue proceedings in the Crown Court up until the trial, bringing its opportunity to do so in line with the opportunity in the magistrates’ court. Importantly, this change would mean that proceedings could be ended at a later point and still be reinstated where it is determined that the prosecution was ended in error. For victims, this would be an important safeguard, enabling them to exercise their right meaningfully to challenge CPS decision-making. One might ask why this change is needed. Currently, the CPS can end proceedings in two principal ways in the Crown Court. It can do so within a narrow timeframe by discontinuing proceedings, which allows it to reinstate proceedings at a later point, or it can offer no evidence, which it can do right up until the start of the trial. The latter is, in effect, an acquittal of the defendant, meaning that even where proceedings are ended in error, there are no means to reinstate them. Following campaigning by a victim known as Jade Blue, who was subject to this procedure, in June 2025 the CPS launched a pilot in the West Midlands for rape cases, enabling survivors to be told that a decision has been made to offer no evidence and to request a review before final closure. This approach aims to provide an additional safeguard, allowing decisions to be reconsidered before proceedings are halted. We are told that this scheme is being robustly evaluated to ensure that the right balance is struck between victims’ rights to review, the requirements of the court process and the defendant’s rights to timely notification. I would be happy if the Minister could update us on exactly where that has got to, and whether it is likely to be rolled out. Would this increase the likelihood of more cases being reinstated? One concern that the Government may have is that this would enable the Crown Prosecution Service to take this up rather enthusiastically and be even more exercised in stopping some of these cases happening. Yet discontinuance processes or powers are quite common in a variety of jurisdictions, not just in this country. They are common in several Australian territories and New Zealand, and are available in Scotland, the United States of America and Canada. All the evidence shows that rates of reinstatement are extremely low, even where the regime is more liberal than it is in this country. This tends to indicate that prosecutor behaviour limits the use of the power to reinstate cases to those very rare ones of wrong decisions or where further evidence has become available, and to use the theoretically wide power sparingly and only where appropriate. The power to discontinue is already available in magistrates’ court up to the point of trial in England and Wales. Even so, reinstatement there is so rare that it is difficult to find any examples of its use. That is the case we are putting forward. For a small group of victims, this would be a very important right and would not leave a victim of rape or a sexual offence hanging at the point that they thought there might be a trial, where they are told that not only would there not be a trial but there was no chance of a trial in future. For all those reasons, I hope the Government will answer in a compelling and full way, and above all will indicate where their thinking is at the moment and how this process of evaluating a new way of doing this is proceeding.

More from Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.