Contribution
My Lords, my Amendment 52 is a practical amendment based on a simple proposition: where a child witness or a witness already recognised by law as vulnerable or intimidated wishes to use a screen, live link or prerecorded evidence in chief, they should not have to apply for it. It should be available automatically, unless there is good reason not to allow it. These are not exceptional measures. They are not novel. Nor are they granted only in rare circumstances. Prerecorded evidence in chief, screens and live links are the three most common special measures used in criminal courts every day all over the country. In the overwhelming majority of cases, applications are made, considered and granted as a matter of routine.
If that is the reality, we should ask a simple question: why are we still requiring vulnerable witnesses to jump through a procedural hoop to obtain something that everybody expects them to receive anyway? The current process creates delay, paperwork and uncertainty—more importantly, uncertainty for victims and witnesses. Giving evidence is often the most stressful part of the criminal justice process. Many victims spend months, sometimes years, worrying about what will happen when they finally enter that courtroom. They deserve clarity from the outset about the basic protections that will be available to them but, instead, we tell them that an application has been made and that a decision will follow. Technically, that is true but, in reality, the measure is almost certain to be granted, so what purpose is served by making vulnerable witnesses prove that they need what everybody already knows they need and are overwhelmingly likely to be given?
My amendment would reverse that: it would provide that eligible witnesses were entitled to these basic and routinely used measures without having to make a formal application. They could simply indicate which measure they wished to use and the court would grant it, unless there were compelling reasons why doing so would be contrary to the interests of justice.
I anticipate that my noble friend the Minister may raise a number of concerns, so I want to anticipate what she is going to say and address that. The first may be that judicial discretion must be preserved. I agree entirely; that is precisely why this amendment preserves it. The court would retain an explicit power to refuse a measure where it would be contrary to the interests of justice. Defendants retain the right to object, and judges retain complete control over how the arrangements operate in practice. The amendment would remove unnecessary bureaucracy, not judicial judgment.
The second possible objection is that not every court can currently provide every measure in every case. Again, I understand that concern, but I do not believe that it is a reason for maintaining the present system. The Government are rightly investing in specialist rape and serious sexual offences courts and are to be commended for doing so. More broadly, screens, live links and video evidence facilities are now a normal part of criminal court infrastructure across England and Wales. If there are still places where these basic facilities are lacking, the answer is surely to improve the provision of the facilities or to move the case to a better equipped court and not to deny vulnerable witnesses a presumption in favour of their use. The risk that the infrastructure may occasionally—in my experience, rarely—fall short cannot justify preserving a system that routinely creates uncertainty for thousands of victims.
The third argument may be that better information and guidance can achieve the same outcome. I respectfully disagree. Better information is welcome, but it is not the same as better rights. A victim can be given excellent information about special measures and still be left wondering whether those measures will be available when they come to give evidence. Information cannot provide certainty; a statutory entitlement can.
There is also a wider practical benefit. Every routine application consumes time and wastes scarce public money. Police officers have to prepare paperwork; prosecutors then have to review that paperwork; the defence representatives then consider the paperwork, and the judges then also consider it and must determine it. All that effort is expended for an outcome that is, in most cases, entirely predictable. When the courts are under enormous pressure, we should be asking whether scarce resources are being used wisely. Surely judges should be spending their time deciding genuinely contested issues rather than processing applications that everyone expects to succeed.
My amendment adopts a practical and proportionate approach. It applies only to the most common and least controversial measures. It does not extend to measures such as prerecorded cross-examination under Section 28 or other arrangements that might require a more detailed judicial assessment. Those would continue to be dealt with through the ordinary application process, so this is not a radical amendment but a modest and targeted reform. Indeed, Scotland has already moved in this direction through its vulnerable witness reforms. Parliament there has recognised that some standard measures have become so routinely appropriate that requiring an application no longer serves a useful purpose. In truth, that is where we are as well. We would not design this system in this way if we were starting from scratch today.
The amendment says that where Parliament has already recognised that a witness is vulnerable and the protection sought is routinely granted in courts across the country, the default position should be that the witness receives it. It would reduce bureaucracy, save judicial and prosecutorial time, preserve defendants’ rights and preserve judicial discretion. Above all, it would give vulnerable witnesses something that they too often lack: a measure of certainty. For those reasons, I hope the Government will look favourably on this reform.