Contribution
My Lords, the railway works best when it reflects the needs and priorities of the community it serves. That is why the Bill establishes a statutory role for devolved Governments and strategic authorities within the future railway. I am pleased to announce that the Bill has already received legislative consent from the Scottish Parliament and that Welsh Ministers laid their recommendation to support the Bill on 6 November.
The Bill places devolved leaders at the heart of railway decision-making. GBR will be required to have regard to their transport plans and strategies, consult them before taking decisions that significantly affect their areas, and work with them through formal co-operation arrangements. These measures will help ensure that local priorities are taken into account in decisions about rail services, stations and wider transport integration, while providing a flexible framework that can adapt to different local circumstances and support stronger partnerships over time. The government amendments, and Amendment 4 in the name of my noble friend Lord Blunkett, build on that framework in three areas: strengthening our partnership with the devolved Governments, reinforcing the importance of local partnerships and extending key provisions to foundation strategic authorities.
Before turning to the amendments, I want to address the point raised by my noble friend Lord Boateng in Committee about the role of the railway in supporting regional economic growth. He was right to highlight its importance then and during our recent meeting with my honourable friend the Member for Hastings and Rye. The public interest duty in the Bill explicitly enables GBR to consider social and economic benefits, recognising that these important factors are linked. Economic growth and the genuine needs of communities must be considered together, and considered locally, regionally and nationally. This priority will also be reflected in the long-term rail strategy. In fact, the discussion document published last month specifically outlines the role of our railways in harnessing regional economic growth and highlights the areas that GBR will consider in order to deliver this. This an important topic and I look forward to discussing it further during the passage of the regulating for growth Bill.
On government Amendment 14, in securing Welsh Ministers’ support for the Bill, I committed to include a dedicated chapter on Wales and the borders within the statement of objectives issued as part of each funding settlement. Amendment 14 places that commitment on a statutory footing. I am pleased that we have been able to reach agreement on this issue, and I thank Mark Hooper MS, the Deputy Minister for Transport in Wales, and his officials for their constructive engagement throughout. The close collaboration between our Governments has helped to ensure that these reforms work for passengers and communities in Wales and the borders.
The statement of objectives will help guide the future partnership between Transport for Wales and Great British Railways. It demonstrates both our commitment to working with the Welsh Government and the importance that we attach to the memorandum of understanding that underpins that relationship.
On strategic authorities and Amendment 4, I thank my noble friend Lord Blunkett for tabling this amendment and for his constructive engagement on this issue since Committee. I also thank him and the noble Lord, Lord Harper, for their kind words. I totally agree with my friend, the noble Lord, that the partnership provisions in the Bill must operate in practice as well as in principle. GBR should engage seriously with proposals from local leaders, and the bar for GBR to reject a partnership must be exceptionally high.
Mayors, in particular, have a vital role to play in the future railway. They understand the needs of their communities, have responsibility for wider transport networks and economic growth and are best placed to bring rail together with local transport priorities. A nationally integrated railway must therefore work in close partnership with local leaders if it is to succeed. The Bill gives strategic authorities a strong statutory role within the railway. GBR will be required to have regard to their transport plans and strategies, consult them on decisions that significantly affect their areas and work with them through formal co-operation arrangements. These provisions are designed to ensure that mayors are more than simply engaged stakeholders and will play a meaningful role in shaping the railway in their areas.
We are already putting that approach into practice. Each mayoral strategic authority now has a nominated railway leader from the industry. This provides mayors with a single point of accountability for rail matters in their area. We are working with the rail industry to establish mayoral-led local partnership boards across the established mayoral strategic authorities. Memoranda of understanding have been agreed in West Yorkshire and the north-east, allowing mayors to set out their priorities clearly ahead of the creation of GBR.
Across Yorkshire, we are working with the mayors to build on the white rose agreement and the work led by my noble friend Lord Blunkett on improving rail connectivity across Yorkshire. Through that collaboration, government, local leaders and the rail industry are working together to deliver a railway that better supports Yorkshire’s communities and economy. We are seeing the same commitment to strong local partnership in Greater Manchester. Local and rail industry partners are already working together to integrate rail into the Bee Network, with pay-as-you-go rail schemes in the region being introduced as part of the phased Bee Network integration from this December. We are also working with Transport for Greater Manchester to develop the scope for a future local commissioning partnership. This could see the mayor funding and commissioning outcomes from GBR, further supporting the role of rail alongside the Bee Network.
That is the kind of relationship we want to see between GBR and local leaders. Where a partnership proposal is not taken forward, there should be transparency about why. This amendment will therefore require GBR to publish a reasoned explanation where it decides not to enter into proposed arrangements or arrangements that are substantially similar. That will provide transparency and accountability while preserving the flexibility needed to reach the right outcome in each case. Thus, I am pleased to support Amendment 4 and commend it to the House.
On Amendment 46 from the noble Lord, Lord Harper, the Government’s commitment to working closely with mayors does not mean that every request for further devolution should automatically be granted. The Government are committed to rewiring the state, with greater local control of rail services for mayors being a core part of the agenda. We support further rail devolution where it is in the interests of passengers and the wider network. The Bill already provides a route to achieve that. It preserves the existing power to exempt services from designation, while Section 53 of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act 2026 provides a formal route through which established mayoral strategic authorities can seek additional rail powers. Such proposals will be considered by the Secretary of State in accordance with the department’s rail devolution guidance.
This approach is entirely consistent with the principle of devolving by default, set out in the Cabinet statement, Rewiring the State. That principle does not mean that powers must automatically be devolved whenever requested. Rather, it means that decisions should start from a presumption in favour of devolution and consider whether powers can be best exercised locally rather than nationally. As the accompanying policy paper makes clear,
“where policies or services are being designated or altered, Secretaries of State will need to justify holding them at the level of central government”.
In fact, speaking of Greater Manchester, at the time when the now Prime Minister was Mayor of Greater Manchester, commitments in the 2023 devolution deal with Greater Manchester under the previous Government focused on activity better to integrate rail into the local Bee Network—for example, in relation to pay-as-you-go and passenger experience. This activity is continuing, but there has never been a formal request to de-designate services from Greater Manchester.
The right outcome may not always be further devolution. In some cases, it may be a partnership arrangement with GBR or another solution that better achieves local objectives. It is important that the Secretary of State consider each proposal on its merits. This amendment would remove that discretion by requiring services to be exempted whenever a request is made under Section 53, which I do not believe would be the right approach. As the noble Lord, Lord McLoughlin, reflected, the railway is a network of local, regional and long-distance services, and the railway network crosses political boundaries. Whether devolution is appropriate will depend on the operational, safety and financial context of each case. This amendment risks fragmentation of an interconnected national network if the consequences have not been fully considered.
Much of today’s debate has focused on mayoral strategic authorities, but it is equally important that places with no mayor have a meaningful place in the future railway. This is the theme of government Amendments 5, 15, 26, 70, 113, 114, 118, 119, 121 to 125, 135 and 136. These amendments are the result of careful consideration of the points raised in Grand Committee on GBR’s partnership. I am grateful to noble Lords and, in particular, to the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, who is sadly not in his place today, for their thoughtful and detailed representations on this topic since Committee.
The amendments will consider how non-mayoral strategic authorities in England, known as foundation strategic authorities, can benefit from the same core mechanisms in the Bill as their mayoral counterparts. This includes entering into co-operation arrangements with GBR. Meanwhile, GBR will be required to take their transport plans into account and to consult them before taking decisions that could significantly affect their areas. These amendments are particularly relevant to Cornwall Council, following the recent announcement of its designation as a foundation strategic authority. Cornwall already works closely with the railway industry, and these amendments will ensure that that relationship can continue to develop within the framework established by the Bill.
The amendments give foundation strategic authorities a role in other important parts of the Bill, including advising GBR and the Secretary of State on local railway matters, referring issues to the passenger watchdog and contributing to the preparation of statements of objectives. Together, these changes ensure that foundation strategic authorities can help shape rail services in their areas and work with GBR on behalf of their communities. I commend to the House Amendment 4 in the name of my noble friend Lord Blunkett, and I urge the noble Lord, Lord Harper, not to press his amendment.