L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the Minister for his innovative leaping-in at the beginning of the group and helping to set the terms of the debate. That was a useful contribution and helped all of us. Perhaps I may say, briefly, in relation to the noble Lord, Lord Tunnicliffe, that it is not a small residue. On current patterns, 25% of train movements on the network after this system is brought into place will not be GBR movements; they will be non-GBR movements. That is not a small residue. It is to protect the interests of those parties, to understand and ensure that they are protected, fundamentally, that we are embarking on this debate. The fact is that all organisations, even those run by the most professional and well-intentioned people, have a tendency to self-prefer. That is not controversial. It is well established in any business book that you look at. But it is implicitly admitted by the Minister, who would not otherwise have spent a considerable amount of the debate this afternoon explaining how he is going to mitigate against that tendency for self-preference. Can we take that as common ground? While my noble friends Lord Lansley and Lord Young of Cookham explored in detail how those mitigations might work—that was a valuable exposure—it was my noble friend Lord Harper who put his finger on the matter. He asked, “Why are we creating this problem in the first place? We are setting out to create a problem in which there is a reward for self-preference. We don’t have to do it.” My noble friend Lord Harper explained that, when he was in charge of policy formation, the system that he was going to propose did not contain that. You could argue that he was wearing rose-tinted spectacles and that objections could be raised. I am not buying in necessarily to his solution just because it is his, but I am making the point because it shows that there are alternatives that could work better and avoid this enormous problem. I take one example. I will come to my detailed amendments in a moment. Amendment 223 in my name is now defunct because the Government have more or less pre-empted it. There was a conflict in the text between the provisions in the regulations that said that an infrastructure manager could not make a decision about access. The thrust of the Bill is that an infrastructure manager will make a decision about access. My amendment was exploring that but only then did I spot that in the Commons the Government had got ahead of me and had eliminated this prohibition in the pre-existing regulations where an infrastructure manager could not make those decisions, thus actively removing a conflict in the text by creating a conflict of interest. They were building conflicts of interest into the Bill quite deliberately. It is staggering that this is going ahead and being allowed. The Minister says that these things must be internal; it must all be under one directing mind. That is an assertion of faith. There is no evidence that it must all be under one directing mind. My noble friend Lord Harper has given his alternative view, and I could give another. It is perfectly possible—this is the thrust of my clause stand part notices—to say that those access decisions are taken outside the structure by an independent decision-maker; it does not have to be a regulator, as such. The ORR is making those decisions already. They are to be moved inside. Why? Only for the purpose of creating conflicts of interest, which will almost certainly work themselves out badly, and the protections are almost entirely internal. The Minister refers to appeals to the Competition and Markets Authority. That is a fine body. It comes to mind that, for many years, it produced reports saying that competition in the supermarket sector was robust and did not need to be challenged by the regulator. Then Aldi and Lidl came along, and we found out just how robust the competition was in the supermarket sector, as it collapsed in every direction when new efficiencies were introduced by new competitors. Last week I asked a Question in the Chamber about the huge premium—20p a litre—being charged on fuel in motorway service stations. The Minister admitted that the Competition and Markets Authority had found that there was weak competition in that sector. We have known for years that there has been weak competition. What has been done about it? If you represent a heritage railway, let us say the Dean Forest Railway, and you cannot get access to the Great British Railways network that you need for the services and activities that you are undertaking in the next six months or so, there is absolutely no point in going to the Competition and Markets Authority to talk about it; that is the wrong address to go to. As for the ORR, we know that the Bill deliberately confines the basis of its appeals to procedural matters that are akin to judicial review proceedings. The Minister today sent a letter of several pages, which I have seen, to my noble friend Lord Lansley, following a meeting they had. All it did was to describe how judicial review works; there was nothing more in it than that. Everything in it we know already; nothing is being added to this at all. It is deliberately setting out to create conflicts of interests. I will not, therefore, spend much more time on my amendments. My stand part notices for Clauses 59 and 69 would, in effect, keep the decisions on access with the ORR, which has a track record in doing it. Let us also bear in mind that, after all, Network Rail, DFTO and the various components that will go together to make Great British Railways do not have any expertise in doing this at the moment. The expertise, such as it is, is with the ORR. This all has to be built from scratch. They have no experience of doing this, but it is all being transferred to them and taken away from the people who might know what they were doing. I have referred to Amendment 223. Amendments 227 and 251 are much more minor. Amendment 227 would require the access and use statement, which we will not see in its final form until the spring, to be subject to parliamentary scrutiny. Amendment 251 would require formal consultation on the access and use policy with the open access operators and others. I know that the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, does not see the need to have that in the Bill, but it is quite common to have consultation requirements in Bills and in such processes as planning processes and so forth. They are statutory consultation requirements. They become statutory because they are referred to in a Bill; it is very common. I would go further and remind noble Lords that there are powers in the Bill to revise and replace this document, and open access operators should be statutory consultees when revisions arise—not simply on the first iteration of the document. This should apply to freight and heritage railways and other users of the infrastructure, too.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.